Journal of Iranian Architecture & Urbanism(JIAU)

Gated Communities: Genesis, Proliferation, Types and Consequences

Document Type : Review Paper

Authors

Mohammad Jalili 1
Alireza Einifar 2
Ramin Madani 3
Bruce Judd 4

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Architecture, Borujerd Branch, Islamic Azad University, Borujerd, Iran

2 Professor, School of Architecture, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

3 Assistant Professor, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Design, Art University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran

4 Professor Emeritus, City Futures Research Centre, Faculty of Built Environment, University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia

https://doi.org/10.30475/isau.2020.228678.1401
Abstract
Extended abstract
The emergence and spread of planned residential developments with hard and controllable boundaries called gated communities and the social consequences of living in such communities have attracted the attention of researchers for decades. The increasing growth of these communities signifies a new form of residence and has led to many studies on how and why these communities emerged. Despite the emergence of gated communities in Iran in the 1960s, there is a dearth of research on such communities in Iran. Reviewing theories and empirical studies conducted in this area, this paper is an attempt to examine the existing definitions of gated communities, their types, causes of their expansion, and their positive and negative consequences.
The origins of gated communities can be traced back to the previous century and the strong fortifications of ancient cities which were built to protect against invaders, enemies or even wild animals. Systems of class segregation and differentiation such as citadels and fortified cities, common in ancient Iran, were designed to protect against enemies and strangers and prevent them from entering the community. During the early Islamic period, the walls and gates of the inner city were destroyed. In this period, encouraging the expansion of the outer city, that is, part of the city whose people did not belong to upper social classes, toward middle city was the most important policy adopted by the Islamic state. The disappearance of the walls and gates of the inner city and a new relationship between the new government and people who were oppressed before then led to the formation of new strata in opposition to the old strata. The inner walls and gates were destroyed in an effort to bring justice and eliminate class segregation. However, as a sign of city’s defensive power, the outer walls remained intact to protect from attack and enhance security.
It seems that new gated communities first appeared during the early 1960s with the enforcement of the third (1963-1967) and fourth (1968-1972) Reconstruction Plans of the country. During this period, as housing proved to be a major issue, housing provision by the private sector burgeoned. The target profile was an emerging social class formed owing to the economic and political changes of the early 1960s. With the formation of the new social class and the entry of the private sector into housing market, gated residential communities became a marketing opportunity and a means of attracting particular markets for private housing developers. The developers of large-scale projects started their research considering this reality and the needs of the new social class. Although the first gated community of the country appeared in Tehran, today, gated communities have increased their market share not only in big cities but also in smaller cities of the nation. Gated communities have four main features: (1) impermeable boundary and controlled access to the community, (2) shared private ownership of common spaces and private access to them, (3) the presence of private facilities and amenities for communal use of residents, and (4) the presence of a common code of conduct to regulate behaviors and activities.
According to existing typologies, gated communities in Iran can be grouped into lifestyle, prestige, and security zone communities. Lifestyle communities focus on leisure activities and shared amenities and facilities offered within the community attracting those looking for an identity and a shared lifestyle. Examples of lifestyle communities in Iran are Daryakenar and Lavasan. Prestige communities attract people caring about the image of their socio-economic situation symbolizing wealth and social status. Such communities are exemplified by developments such as Park in Isfahan and Saeedieh in Hamedan. Security zone communities in Iran include communities that were not originally gated but were later gated by residents. In such communities, public streets are often closed to non-residents. Ekbatan is such a community in Tehran.
The advocates of gated housing claim that gated communities meet individuals’ needs for security, identity, and sense of community; provide services and infrastructure in the areas that were not previously well-equipped; secure property values; prevent outsiders from entering the community; provide a safer environment for pedestrians due to their lower traffic flow; and often feature high quality spaces and attractive amenities.
Those against gated communities emphasize the social costs of gated communities. They believe that gated developments are a threat to social integration and their expansion has led to many physical and social problems in urban areas. Social differentiation leads to the fragmentation and segmentation of the society.
Despite these negative views on gated communities, it is unignorable that there is an increase in demand to live in such developments. Neither the demand in the housing market nor the negative consequences of gated communities can be denied. Hence, it is necessary to find a way to achieve a balance between their consequences and mediate their negative effects since gated communities have the potential to become even more prevalent in the landscape of cities in coming decades.

Keywords

Gated Communities
Hard Boundaries
Gating
Globalization
Club Goods
Atkinson, R., & Blandy, S. (2013). Gated communities: International perspectives. Routledge.
Atkinson, R., Blandy, S., Flint, J., & Lister, D. (2003). Gated communities in England : final report of the gated communities in England 'New Horizons' project. Glasgow: University of Glasgow, Department of Urban Studies.
Atkinson, R., & Flint, J. (2004). Fortress UK? Gated communities, the spatial revolt of the elites and time–space trajectories of segregation. Housing studies, 19(6), 875-892.
Akgün, A. A., & Baycan, T. (2011). Gated communities in Istanbul: the new walls of the city. Town Planning Review, 83(1), 87-109.
Bagaeen, S., & Uduku, O. (Eds.). (2015). Beyond gated communities. Routledge.
Baycan-Levent, T., & Gülümser, A. A. (2007). Gated communities in Istanbul: The new walls of the city. EURODIV paper.
Blandy, S. (2018). Gated communities revisited: defended homes nested in security enclaves. People, Place & Policy Online, 11(3).
Blandy, S. (2006). Gated communities in England: historical perspectives and current developments. GeoJournal, 66(1-2), 15-26.
Branic, N., & Kubrin, C. E. (2018). Gated Communities and Crime in the United States. The Oxford Handbook of Environmental Criminology, 401.
Breetzke, G. D., Landman, K., & Cohn, E. G. (2014). Is it safer behind the gates? Crime and gated communities in South Africa. Journal of housing and the built environment, 29(1), 123-139.
Borsdorf, A., Hidalgo, R., & Sánchez, R. (2007). A new model of urban development in Latin America: The gated communities and fenced cities in the metropolitan areas of Santiago de Chile and Valparaíso. Cities, 24(5), 365-378.
Blakely, E. J. (1999). The gated community debate. Urban Land, 58, 50-55.
Blakely, E. J., & Snyder, M. G. (1997). Fortress America: gated communities in the United States. Brookings Institution Press.
Byers, M. (2003). Waiting at the Gate: The New, Postmodern Promised Lands. Suburban Sprawl: Culture, Ecology and Politics Eds H Bartling, M Lindstrom (Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham, MD) pp, 23-44.
Caldeira, T. P. (2000). City of walls: crime, segregation, and citizenship in São Paulo. University of California Press.
Christensen, K., & Levinson, D. (Eds.). (2003). Encyclopedia of community: From the village to the virtual world.
Community Association Institute. (1999). National Survey of Community Association Homeowner Satisfaction (Alexandria: CAI).
Coy, M. (2006). Gated communities and urban fragmentation in Latin America: the Brazilian experience. GeoJournal, 66(1-2), 121-132.
Council for Scientific & Industrial Research (CSIR) (2002). Guidelines for Human Settlement Planning and Design. Council for Scientific & Industrial Research, Pretoria.
Davis, M. (1990). City of Quartz: Excavating the Future in Los Angeles. London: Verso.
Davis, M. (1998). Ecology of fear: Los Angeles and the imagination of disaster. Macmillan.
Einifar, A., Madani, R., Judd, B., & Jalili, M. (2019). The Physical Factors Affecting the Social Livability of Gated Communities: A Case study of Gated Communities in Tehran. IJAUP, 29 (2) :127-139
Ellin, N. (1997). Architecture of fear. Princeton Architectural Press.
Foldvary, F. (1994). Public goods and private communities: the market provision of social services. Edward Elgar, London.
Foucault, M. (1975). Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. New York: Radom House.
Ghanbari, A., & Zaheri, M. (2011). Evaluation of housing MACRO polices in Pre and post Islamic revolution of IRAN, Housing and Rural Environment, 30(1), 77-90.
Glasze, G. (2005). Some reflections on the economic and political organisation of private neighbourhoods. Housing studies, 20(2), 221-233.
Glasze, G., & Alkhayyal, A. (2002). Gated housing estates in the Arab world: case studies in Lebanon and Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 29(3), 321-336.
Grant, J. L. (2008). Challenging the public realm: gated communities in history. Halifax, Canada: School of Planning, Dalhousie University.
Grant, J. L. (2007). Two sides of a coin? New urbanism and gated communities. Housing Policy Debate, 18(3), 481-501.
Grant, J. (2005). Planning responses to gated communities in Canada. Housing Studies, 20(2), 273-285.
Grant, J., & Mittelsteadt, L. (2004). Types of gated communities. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 31(6), 913-930.
Güzey, Ö. (2014). Neoliberal urbanism restructuring the city of Ankara: Gated communities as a new life style in a suburban settlement. Cities, 36, 93-106.
Habibi, M. (2007). From town to city: A historical analysis of urban design and its physical aspect. Tehran, Iran: University of Tehran Press.
Harvey, D. (2005). A Brief History of Neoliberalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hillier, J., & McManus, P. (1994). Pull up the drawbridge: fortress mentality in the suburbs. Metropolis now: planning and the urban in contemporary Australia, 91-107.
Jalili, M. (2020). The Effects of Residential Communities’ Physical Boundaries on Residents’ Perception of Fear of Crime and Sense of Community: A Comparison Between Gated, Perceived Gated, and Non-gated Communities in Ekbatan Town, Doctoral dissertation, Art University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran.
Janoschka, M., & Borsdorf, A. (2006). Condominios fechados and barrios privados: the rise of private residential neighbourhoods in Latin America (pp. 92-108).
Judd, D. (1995). The rise of the new walled cities. Spatial practices, 11(1), 144-145.
Kalantari, S., Rafieian, M., Aghasafari, A., & Kalantari, H. (2017). Gated communities: Problems and solutions, case study: DARYA-KENAR gated community, ARMANSHAHR Architecture and Urban Development, 10(6), 217-33.
Kim, S. K. (2006). The gated community: Residents' crime experience and perception of safety behind gates and fences in the urban area, Doctoral dissertation, Texas A&M University.
Landman, K. (2000). Gated Communities and Urban Sustainability: Taking a closer look at the future. In 2nd Southern African Conference on Sustainable Development in the Built Environment Strategies for Sustainable Built Environment, Pretoria, South Africa, 23-25 August 2000.
Landman, K. (2002a). Transforming urban spaces in South Africa: the impact of enclosed neighbourhoods on the urban future. Transforming Rural and Urban Spaces in South Africa During the 1990s: Reform, Restitution, Restructuring, 205-225.
Landman, K. (2002b). Gated communities in South Africa: building bridges or barriers. In international conference on private urban governance, Mainz, Germany (Vol. 649).
Leisch, H. (2002). Gated communities in Indonesia. Cities, 19(5), 341-350.
Le Goix, R., & Vesselinov, E. (2013). Gated communities and house prices: Suburban change in southern California, 1980–2008. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 37(6), 2129-2151.
Le Goix, R., & Webster, C. J. (2008). Gated communities. Geography Compass, 2(4), 1189-1214.
Low, S. (2016). Spatializing culture: The ethnography of space and place. Routledge.
Low, S. (2003). Behind the gates. New York and London: Routledge.
Lyon, L. (1987). The community in urban society. Chicago, IL: Dorspy Press.
Madani, R., Einifar, A., Judd, B., & Jalili, M. (2019). Factors Affecting the Development of Sense of Community in Gated Communities: A Case Study of Gated Communities in Hamedan. ARMANSHAHR Architecture and Urban Development, 11(25), 163-176.
Mantey, D. (2017). Social consequences of gated communities: The case of suburban Warsaw. The Professional Geographer, 69(1), 151-161.
Maxwell, K. D. (2004). Gated communities: selling the good life. Master's thesis. School of Planning, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia.
McKenzie, E. (2003). Common‐interest housing in the communities of tomorrow. Housing policy debate, 14(1-2), 203-234.
Németh, J., & Schmidt, S. (2011). The privatization of public space: modeling and measuring publicness. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 38(1), 5-23.
Pow, C. P. (2007a). Securing the'civilised'enclaves: Gated communities and the moral geographies of exclusion in (post-) socialist shanghai. Urban studies, 44(8), 1539-1558.
Pow, C. P. (2007b). Constructing a new private order: gated communities and the privatization of urban life in post-reform Shanghai. Social & Cultural Geography, 8(6), 813-833.
Rofe, M. W. (2006). New landscapes of gated communities: Australia's Sovereign Islands. Landscape Research, 31(3), 309-317.
Roitman, S. (2010). Gated communities: definitions, causes and consequences. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Urban Design and Planning, 163(1), 31-38.
Sorkin, M. (1992). Variations on a Theme Park: The New American City and the End of Public Space. New York: Hill & Wang.
Stoyanov, P., & Frantz, K. (2006). Gated communities in Bulgaria: interpreting a new trend in post-communist urban development. GeoJournal, 66(1-2), 57-63.
Shapiro, M. J. (2009). Managing urban security: City walls and urban metis. Security Dialogue, 40(4-5), 443-461.
Tan, T. H. (2016). Residential satisfaction in gated communities: Case study of desa park city, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Property Management, 34(2), 84-99.
Tang, B. (2017). China's Housing Middle Class: Changing Urban Life in Gated Communities. Routledge.
Touman, A. H. (2002). Gated communities: Physical construction or social destruction tool. Grenoble, University Pierre Mendes France.
Varna, G., & Tiesdell, S. (2010). Assessing the publicness of public space: The star model of publicness. Journal of Urban Design, 15(4), 575-598.
Vesselinov, E. (2010). Gated communities in the United States: From case studies to systematic evidence. Sociology Compass, 4(11), 989-998.
Vesselinov, E., Cazessus, M., & Falk, W. (2007). Gated communities and spatial inequality. Journal of Urban Affairs, 29(2), 109-127.
Webster, C. (2001). Gated cities of tomorrow. Town Planning Review, 72(2), 149-170.
Webster, C. (2002). Property rights and the public realm: gates, green belts, and Gemeinschaft. Environment and Planning B: Planning and design, 29(3), 397-412.
Webster, C., Glasze, G., & Frantz, K. (2002). 2002: The global spread of gated communities. Environment and Planning B, Planning and Design, 29(1), 315-20.
Webster, C. J., Wu, F., & Zhao, Y. (2006). China’s modern walled cities. In Private cities: Local and global perspectives. G. Glasze, C. Webster and K. Frantz K eds. Pp. 153-169. Routledge, London.
Wilson-Doenges, G. (2000). An exploration of sense of community and fear of crime in gated communities. Environment and behavior, 32(5), 597-611.
Xu, M. (2009). Gated communities in China: urban design concerns (Doctoral dissertation, Cardiff University).
Xu, M., & Yang, Z. (2008). Theoretical debate on gated communities: genesis, controversies, and the way forward. Urban Design International, 13(4), 213-226.
Zaiotti, R. (2007). Of friends and fences: Europe’s neighbourhood policy and the ‘gated community syndrome’. European Integration, 29(2), 143-162.
Zaireen, Z. A., Norhidayah, M. Y., Razali, M. N., Maslinda, A. L., Hussin, K., & Zakaria, S. R. A. (2015). The Typology of Gated Communities from Housing Developers’ Perspective. Advanced Science Letters, 21(5), 1247-1250

  • Receive Date 27 January 2020
  • Revise Date 07 April 2020
  • Accept Date 25 May 2020

Home

Guide for Authors

Submit Manuscript

Reviewers

Contact Us