Document Type : Original Research Paper

Authors

1 M.A. in Architecture, Department of Architecture, Jundi-Shapur University of Technology, Dezful, Iran.

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Architecture, Jundi-Shapur University of Technology, Dezful, Iran.

Abstract

Extended Abstract
Background and Objectives: Traditionally, the public has used Ab-Anbars (water reservoirs) in hot and dry areas and also in cold regions of Iran. One of the main elements of Ab-Anbar is the reservoir coverage (reservoir lining), which is made of various brick vaults such as barrel and colombo vaults with different rises and forms. Due to the dry weather in most parts of Iran and insufficient rainfall in more than six months of the year in most places, which has resulted in the seasonality of rivers and the lack of access to water, various arrangements have been established for freshwater supply in dry seasons. The construction of the Ab-Anbar (water reservoir and cistern) is one of the innovative ways to supply drinking water. In this regard, the Ab-Anbar, as its name implies, is used to store water in rainy seasons to be used for the rest of the year. The main structure of the Ab-Anbar consists of an underground storage tank and a dome to cover it. In some areas in Iran, a wind catcher is added to this structure to keep the water cool in summer. The construction material used for Ab-Anbars was a special mortar called Sarooj, which was made of sand, clay, lime, goat hair, egg whites, and ash in specific proportions, depending on the location and climate of the place. Some Ab-Anbars had rectangular storage tanks, and some tanks had a cylindrical shape. This study aims to determine the amount of solar radiation received on the surfaces and heat flow inside the Ab-Anbar domes of Qazvin, which leads to recognizing the most optimal form of reservoir coverage for Ab-Anbars among the studied samples. 
Methods: The data, including dry and humid temperature, air, radiation, and current radiation situation of Qazvin city weather station, were prepared over a ten-year period (1996-2006). The library documents also provided the map of the Ab-Anbar domes. In order to conduct the research, four samples of Ab-Anbars with different dome structures in Qazvin city were selected. After that, the domes were modeled in Revit 2016, and the amount of solar radiation received by the domes on the hottest day of the year, at 14, 16, and 18 o’clock, were determined using honeybee & ladybug plugins with Energy plus Engine. COMSOL software, and the CFD airflow analysis, were performed for validation in high-rise and low-rise domes. 
Findings: The results of the analyses showed that low-rise domes with large surface contact receive more heat than high-rise domes with a small surface contact, and the area of the domes is effective in receiving the sun radiation. Sardar Kouchak (Little Commander) dome, a low-rise dome, is approximately exposed to its total surfaces and solar heat by 84.3% at 14 o’clock. In comparison, the high-rise dome next to the Grand Mosque is exposed by 52.5% at 14 o’clock. The low-rise dome is exposed by 74.7%, while the high-rise dome is exposed by 53.5% at 16 o’clock. Finally, the low-rise dome is exposed by 62.4%, and the high-rise dome is exposed by 43.2% at 18 o’clock. Therefore, low-rise domes in the cold climate are more efficient in receiving solar radiation than high-rise ones.
Conclusion: The airflow inside the domes was graphically performed for validation using CFD analysis on a hot day. The results are consistent with the outputs from honeybee & ladybug plugins. Low-rise domes can retain more heat than high-rise domes, and the vortex of hot air created in low-rise domes is less than in high-rise domes, which leads to more heat gain inside the dome. Therefore, the most suitable dome for Ab-Anbar in the cold climate of Qazvin are low-rise domes.

Graphical Abstract

Energy optimization of the Ab-Anbar domes; Case study: Domes of Qazvin city

Highlights

- Selection of several examples of reservoirs with different structures in terms of form and shape.
- Simulating the absorption of sunlight and creating shadows on the surfaces of the domes with Honeybee and Ladybug plugins and CFD simulation with COMSOL software.
- The use of low-rising domes is more suitable and optimal than high-rising domes for cold climates.

Keywords

این مقاله برگرفته از پایان‌نامه کارشناسی‌ارشد نویسنده نخست با عنوان «طراحی اسکان موقت با رویکرد بهینه‌سازی حرارتی بر گرفته از پتانسیل‌های گنبد آب انبارها» می‌باشد که به راهنمایی نویسنده دوم و مشاوره نویسنده سوم در دانشگاه صنعتی جندی‌شاپور دزفول انجام گرفته است.

This article is derived from the first author`s Master thesis entitled “Designing a temporary accommodation with a thermal optimization approach based on the potentials of the dome of Ab-Anbars ”, supervised by the second author and advised by the third, at Jundi-Shapur University of Technology Dezful.

  1. Akbari, H., Berdahl, P., Levinson, R., Wiel, S., Miller, W. Desmarais, A.(2006). Cool-color roofing material, PIER Building End-use Energy Efficiency ProgramNo.CEC-500-2006-067.California Energy Commission.
  2. Arefmanesh A, Dehghan A.A, Dehghani A, (2008). Thermal characteristics of an underground cold-water reservoir: Analytical and experimental studies. Applied Thermal Engineering (29): 3261-3265.  
  3. Bowen, A.B. (1981). Cooling Achievement in the Gardens of Moghul India. C. Bowen, K. Labs (Eds.), In Proceeding of the International Passive and Hybrid Cooling Conference, 27-32. Miami Beach, FL, 6–16 November.
  4. Cheikh, H. Ben & Bouchair, A. (2008). Experimental studies of a passive cooling roof in hot arid areas. Revue des Energies Renouvelables, 11, pp.515–522.
  5. Dehghan A.A, Dehghani A.R.)2010(. Experimental and theoretical investigation of Thermal performance of underground cold-water reservoir, International Journal of Thermal Science (50): 816-824.
  6. Faghih K.A, Bahadori M.N. (2008). Solar radiation on domed roofs, Energy and Buildings (41): 1238-1245.
  7. Fathy, H. (1973). Architecture for the Poor. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, London.
  8. Fouladi V, Tahbaz M and H Majdi. (2015). "Double-shell dome from the perspective of thermal performance in the desert climate of Kashan". Islamic Architecture Research Quarterly, 11th issue, summer 2015, 4th year.
  9. Ghobadian, V. (2013). Climate study of traditional Iranian buildings. Tehran: Tehran University.
  10. Gilani, S; B, Mohammadkari. (2019). "Investigating the heating performance of solar greenhouses in residential buildings in cold climates, a case study: Ardabil city", Modares Mechanical Engineering Journal. Volume 11, Number 2, Summer 2019, pp. 147-157.
  11. Hadavand M, Yaghoubi M, Emdad H. )2007(. Thermal analysis of vaulted roofs. Energy and Buildings (40): 265-275.
  12. Kasmai, M; Ahmadinejad, M. (1999). "Climate and Architecture", Khak Publishing House, Tehran
  13. Khoshab M, Dehghan A.A. (2014). Numerical simulation of mixed convection Airflow under a Dome-shaped roof, Arab J Sci Eng (39): 1359-1374.
  14. Koita, Y. (1981). Comfort Attainment in Moghul Architecture. In Proceedings of the International Passive and Hybrid Cooling Conference, 32-36. Miami Beach, FL.
  15. Mainstone, R. J. (1983). Developments in Structural Form. M.L.T. Cambridge Press.
  16. Mehran M.S, Kazemi F, J . (2008). Training of Analysis and Comparison of Radiation Intensity
    Absorbed by Dome and Diagonal and Flat Roofs. Journal of Educational Technology 2(4): 249-258.
  17. Memarian, Gh (1987). "Niarash arch structures in Islamic architecture of Iran", Tehran University of Science and Technology
  18. Memarian, Gh (1992). "Architecture of Yazd Ab-Anbars", Tehran University of Science and Technology.
  19. Memarian, Gh, (2008) Architecture of Qazvin Reservoirs, Athar journal, Fall, 32, pp. 189-201
  20. Memarian, Gh (2011). "Iranian architecture of Niarash", second volume, Nagheme Navandish, Tehran.
  21. Ministry of Energy (2013) "Energy Balance Sheet of 2011", Tehran: Ministry of Energy, Deputy Director General for Electricity and Energy, Office of Planning for Electricity and Energy.
  22. Mohammadzadeh, M, N (2005). "Lasting Monument: Map of Historical Monuments of Qazvin Province", General Directorate of Cultural Tourism and Cultural Heritage of Qazvin Province
  23. Najafi S, Yaghoubi M (2015). Thermal study of a cistern's dome (the case of Motamed cistern in Lar, Iran). Energy and Buildings 102:453–466.
  24. Najafi S, Yaghoubi M (2017). Numerical and experimental study of an under- ground water reservoir, cistern. Water Resour management 322-334.
  25. Nasrollahi, F (2009), Climate and Energy Responsive Housing in Continental Climates The Suitability of Passive Houses for Iran’s Dry and Cold Climate,” PhD thesis Berlin University of Technology”.
  26. Omidvar, k. Ebrahimi, Reza. Mahdavi Nejad, Elham. (2018). “Modeling of the heating degree hours (HDH) at dawn in the dry desert regions of Iran”. Journal of Geographical Research on Desert Areas. 6(1), 1-32.
  27. Qabadian, V (2014). "Climatic survey of Iran's traditional buildings", University of Tehran. Tehran.
  28. Rafiyan, M., (2012). "Qazvin City Atlas", Qazvin Municipality Design Services Organization, Qazvin
  29. Serpooshan, S, Yaghoobi, M. (2002). Calculation of Solar Energy Three-Dimensional Surfaces. Iranian Journal of Energy 7 (13): 3-21.
  30. Shen Xu, Z Huang, J Wang, T Mendis, J. (2019). Huang Evaluation of photovoltaic potential by urban block typology: A case study of Wuhan, China. Renewable Energy Focus, Volume 29 (2019) 141-147. 
  31. Shiri T, Didehban M, M Taban (2018). "Temporary housing design with a thermal optimization approach based on the potentials of reservoir domes". Master's thesis, Jundi-Shapur University of Technology, Dezful
  32. Shiri T, Didehban M, M Taban (2018). "The effect of form on the amount of shading and heat absorption in the dome of Yazd reservoirs". Journal of Islamic Architecture Research. 1398; 7 (4): 75-92
  33. Tang. R. S, Meir I.A., Etzion Y. (2003). An Analysis of Absorbed Radiation by Domed and Vaulted Roofs as Compared with Flat Roofs. Energy and Building 35 (6): 539-548
  34. Victor Gomez M, Gandara M.A.P. (2003). Heared Ch, Solar performance of hemispherical vault roofs, Building and Environment (38): 1431-1438.
  35. Yazhari Kermani, A. Nasrollahi, F. Mahdavinejad, M.J. (2019). The Climate Zoning of Office Buildings with an Emphasis on Radiant Factors in Hot and Dry Regions: A Case Study of Kerman, Journal of Geographical Research on Desert Areas. 7(1), 87-112.
  36. Zinda Del, H (1997). "Comprehensive Iran tour Guide Collection of Qazvin Province", Iran gander Publications, Tehran.