Identification of social and political factors affecting the evolution of planned housing in Kabul (from the 1960s to 2021)

Document Type : Original Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. in Architecture, Faculty of Architecture, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.

2 Professor, Faculty of Architecture, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract
Extended Abstract
Background and Objectives: The transition from tradition to modernity, which began about a century ago in Afghanistan, has deeply affected the core of society and, consequently, its architecture and urban fabric. The planned housing pattern in Kabul has been shaped by Afghanistan’s historical and political events, which have, in turn, influenced the city’s social structure. It is crucial to examine the evolution of housing within the socio-political context of Afghanistan, especially in Kabul, which serves as a model for these changes and reflects the country’s future needs. To design housing that is both suitable and compatible with user requirements, it is essential to study and analyze the various factors that influence housing development. This research aims to explore the relationship between the architectural transformation of housing and the changes in the socio-political structure of society, while also analyzing the factors affecting the transformation of planned housing in Kabul from the 1960s to 2021.
Methods: The research paradigm is qualitative, utilizing a survey method, a questionnaire with a Likert scale, and exploratory factor analysis to examine the impact of socio-political factors on the planned housing pattern of Kabul City. Initially, the historical, political, and social contexts of Afghanistan were considered to identify the components affecting Kabul’s planned housing. These components include population, immigration, social interactions, social groups, family structure, education, security, social justice, and political factors. To assess these socio-political components and determine the key factors driving the transformation of planned housing in Kabul over the past six decades, a survey methodology was used. This involved a 40-question questionnaire with a Likert scale, followed by data analysis. The questionnaire was administered using SPSS software version 26. The KMO value for this data set is 0.521, and the Bartlett’s test value exceeds 95% confidence, confirming the appropriateness of factor analysis for this data set.
Findings: The exploratory factor analysis method was employed to extract ten factors from the variables in the questionnaire, with eigenvalues greater than one. These factors accounted for more than 76% of the cumulative changes. In this analysis, variables with factor loadings greater than 0.4 were placed under the factor with the highest numerical value of factor loadings. The indicators placed under each factor and their conceptual analysis were used to determine the factor’s name, based on the factor’s common characteristics. The exploratory factor analysis of the socio-political components affecting planned housing development in Kabul city over the past six decades indicates that social interactions, internal politics, education and training, housing planning, social trends, social system, women and family, population decline, foreign policy population movement are the most significant factors influencing housing development.
Conclusion: The results of the research indicate that social interactions have had the greatest impact (21%) on the architectural evolution of planned housing in Kabul over the past six decades. The research findings reveal that key factors influencing planned housing in Kabul over the past decades include Afghanistan’s domestic policy (10.1%), education and training (8.5%), housing planning (8.5%), social trends (6.2%), the social system (5.5%), the role of women and family (4.7%), population decline (4.3%), foreign policy (3.9%), and population displacement (3.3%), among other factors. The impact of these factors has fluctuated significantly over time. The majority of changes in housing occurred during the last two decades, which coincided with the period of the Islamic Republic. In contrast, the impact on the planned housing construction process was negative during the period of the Islamic State and the period of the Islamic Emirate. The growth of urbanization in Kabul has increased significantly during the last two decades, with the population of the city increasing sixfold during this period. This has led to a corresponding increase in the construction of settlements, residential complexes, institutional and planned apartments, and high-rise buildings. Many of these constructions have been made in imitation of non-native and foreign examples without consideration of the social and cultural characteristics of the society. Additionally, the examination of the patterns of traditional and planned housing in Kabul City reveals that the aforementioned factors have led to alterations in architectural indicators, including housing typology, architectural style, mass and space ratio, spatial diversity, access method, gender-specific space, interior space organization, communication, horizontal and vertical circulation, architectural decorations and details, facades, materials, and techniques.

Graphical Abstract

Identification of social and political factors affecting the evolution of planned housing in Kabul (from the 1960s to 2021)

Highlights

- To investigate the relationship between Afghanistan’s social and political structure in six government periods (1960-2021) and planned housing developments in Kabul.
- To explain the socio-political factors that influence the transformation of planned housing in Kabul City using the method of exploratory factor analysis.
- Determine the impact of socio-political factors (social interactions, domestic policy, education, housing planning, social trends, social system, women and family, population reduction, foreign policy, and population movement) on the planned housing development of Kabul city.

Keywords

Subjects


این مقاله برگرفته از رساله دکتری نویسنده نخست با عنوان «تحول مسکن برنامه‌ریزی شده شهر کابل در نسبت با تغییرات ساختار اجتماعی-سیاسی افغانستان (از دهة 1960 تا 2021 میلادی)» می‌باشد که به راهنمایی نویسنده دوم و مشاوره نویسنده سوم در دانشگاه تهران انجام گرفته است. 

This article is derived from the first author`s doctoral thesis entitled “The Evolution of Planned Housing Architecture in Kabul City in Relation to Changes in the Social and Political Structure of Afghanistan (from the 1960s to 2021 AD)”, supervised by the second author and advised by the third, at University of Tehran.

  1. Afshari, Mohsen. (2020). Household Social Changes and the Role of Meaning in Dwelling Environment Adjustment, Case Study: Impacts of Subjective Meanings on Tribal Dwelling Changes. Journal of Architectural and Urban Planning, 12(27), 59-78. (In Persian)
  2. Ahmadian, Reza. & Mohammadi, Hamid. (2009). Rural Histology of the Country (General Criteria for Formation of Rural Physical Elements). Tehran: Housing Foundation of Islamic Revolution. (In Persian)
  3. Alalhesabi, Mehran. & Korrani, Naeimeh. (2013). Factors Affecting the Housing Transformation from Past to Future. Journal of Housing and Rural Environment, (141), 19-36. (In Persian)
  4. Amirentekhabi, Shahram. & Hasanlo, Mina. (2019). Explaining the Manner of Formation and Process Development Urban Settlements, Case Study: Manjil City. Quarterly of Geography & Regional Planning, 9(4), 807-826. (In Persian)
  5. Anabestani, Aliakbar. (2013). Analysis of Social Change Impacts on the Pattern of Rural Housing, Case Study: Binalood County. Journal of Research and Rural Planning, 3(5), 57-68. (In Persian)
  6. Ardashiri, Mahyar. & Namdarian, Ahmad Ali. (2006). Diversity, Convergence, and Participation in the Design and Construction of Urban Centers. International Congress on Urban Design, Isfahan. (In Persian)
  7. Asefi, Maziar & Imani, Elnaz. (2014). Recognition and Evaluation of the Transformational Factors of the Spirit of Iranian Traditional Architecture: Originality of the Past, Novelty of Today. Hoviatshahr, 8(19), 63-76. (In Persian)
  8. Ayoobi, Ahmad Walid. & Demirkol, Hatice Günseli (2021). An Evaluation of Architectural Monuments in Afghanistan as in the Capital City, Kabul. Journal of Design for Resilience in Architecture & Planning, 2(1), 64-85.
  9. Ayoobi, Ahmad Walid. & İnceoglu, Mehmet (2021). Mutual Relationship of Culture and Architecture: Focused on Residential Houses in Kabul City.  Journal of Science, Part B: Art, Humanities, Design and Planning, 9(4), 345-356.
  10. Azemati, Hamid Reza., Rostami, Vadood. & Poorbagher, Somaye. (2018). Comparative Comparison of Historical-based and Social-based Background of Urban Housing Spatial Pattern, Case Study: Ardebil City. Iranian Journal of Architecture and Urbanism, (13), 23-32. (In Persian)
  11. Bazregar, Mohammadreza. (2003). Urban Planning and Urban Main Structure. Shiraz: Kooshamehr Publications. (In Persian)
  12. Bentley, Ian (1999). Urban Transformations, Power and Urban Design, USA & Canada: Routledge.
  13. Cerny, Barbara A. & Kaiser, Henry F. (1977). A Study of a Measure of Sampling Adequacy for Factor-analytic Correlation Matrices. Multivar Behav Res., 12(1), 43-47.
  14. Ebrahimi, Somayeh. & Eslami, Gholamreza. (2010). Architecture and Urban Planning of Iran in the Transition Period. Hoviatshahr, 6 (4). 3-14. (In Persian)
  15. Fazali, Zeinab., Pourtaheri, Mahdi. & Rukn al-Din Eftekhari, Abdol Reza. (2018). Analysis of the Changes in Rural Housing in Mazandaran Province, Iran.  Human Geography Research Quarterly, 50(2), 339-354. (In Persian)
  16. Fazeli, Nematollah. (2008). Modernity and Housing. Journal of Iranian Cultural Research, 1(1), 25-63. (In Persian)
  17. Fiske, John. (1993). Power Plays, Power Works, London: Verso Books.
  18. Hagh Shenas, Mahya. &   Hanachi, Pirooz.  (2020). Influencing Factors on Residential Architecture and Lifestyle in Century-old Iran, Case Study: Transformation of Housing Models in the Historical City of Lar. Journal of Iranian Architecture Studies, 17, 57-76. (In Persian)
  19. Hezarjaribi, Jafar. & Emami Ghafari, zeinab. (2019). A Study of Changing House Welfare Policies in Iran (1979-2013). Journal of Social Development and Welfare Planning, 38, 75-119. (In Persian)
  20. Howard, Matt C. (2016). A Review of Exploratory Factor Analysis Decisions and Overview of Current Practices: What We Are Doing and How Can We Improve. International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction, 32(1), 51-62.
  21. Issa, Christine. & Kohistani, Sardar. M. (2007). Kabul's Urban Identity: An Overview of the Socio-Political Aspects of Development. ASIEN 104, 51-64.
  22. Issa, Christine. (2006). Architecture as Symbol of National Identity in Afghanistan. Geographische Rundschau International Edition, 27-32.
  23. Kaiser, Henry. F (1960). The Application of Electronic Computers to Factor Analysis. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 20, 141-151.
  24. Kazimee, Bashir. A. & Najimi, Abdul Wassay. (2017). An Analysis of Urban Regeneration and Architectural Heritage Saving in Kabul since 2001. International Journal of Heritage Architecture, 1(4), 671-682.
  25. Kazimee, Bashir. A. (2006). Sustainable Reconstruction and Planning Strategies for Afghan Cities: Conservation in Cultural and Environmental Heritage. In Fourth International Conference on Urban Regeneration and Sustainability, the Sustainable City IV, 49-60.
  26. Khakpour, Mojgan. & Eshghi Sanati, Hessam. (2015). An Investigation of the Effect of Social and Cultural Factors on the Skeletal Texture of Gilan Province's Villages. 33 (148), 3-20. (In Persian)
  27. Kostof, Spiro. (1991). The City Shaped: Urban Patterns and Meanings through History.  Boston: Little, Brown.
  28. Mirzaalipour, Forough. & Kamilnia, Hamed. (2016). A Study of Political Component in the Formation of Iranian and Turkish Architecture. The Second International Congress on New Horizons in Architecture and Urban Planning with a Development and Technology Approach, Tehran. (In Persian)
  29. Mohammad Hosseini, Parisa., Javan Forouzande, Ali., Jahani Dolatabad, Ismael. & Heidari, Ali Akbar. (2019). An Analysis of the Role of Social Class’s Lifestyle in the Pattern of Housing, Case Study: The Late Qajar and Early Pahlavi Houses in Ardabil. Journal of Bagh-E Nazar, 16(76), 31-44. (In Persian)
  30. Mohammadi Yeganeh, Behrooz., Einali, Jamshid. & Manbari, Parisa. (2020). Analysis of Factors Affecting Livelihood-Based Housing Developments in Urban Peripheral Areas Case: Settlements of Mojezat Rural District of Zanjan County. Journal of Urban Peripheral Development 2(3), 105-126. (In Persian)
  31. Nasr, Tahereh. (2016). The Significance of " Residential Architecture" Paradigm in the Image of Today Iranian Islamic Cities. Journal of Studies On Iranian - Islamic City, 6(22), 67-78. (In Persian)
  32. Nazarian, Tayebeh., Movahedi, Asadullah & Shahabi, Shakib. (2024). Investigating the Construction of a Post-earthquake Shelter Using the Super Adobe Method in Herat, Afghanistan. Urban Planning and Construction, 2(2), 25-39.
  33. Norberg-Shulz, Christian. (2008). Meaning in Western Architecture (Translated by Qayoumi Bidhendi). Tehran: Iranian Academy of the Arts. (In Persian)
  34. Papoli Yazdi, Mohammad Hossein.,  Vosooghi, Fatemeh.  & Labbaf Khaniki, Majid. (2001). Housing in Kurd Tribes in Northern Khorasan Creation and Evolution of the House in View of Cultural and Mental Structures. Geographical Research, (62), 5-29. (In Persian)
  35. Rabbat, Nasser. O., & Schadl, Marcus. (2010). Tradition and Transformation of the Kabuli Courtyard House. In The courtyard House. London: Routledge.
  36. Rapaport, Amos. (2009). Anthropology of Housing. Translated by Afzalian. Tehran: Herfeh Honarmand Publications. (In Persian)
  37. Rapoport, Amos. )1969(, House- Form- Culture. United Kingdom: Prentice-Hall.
  38. Rogers, Richard. (2008). Identity in Architecture.  Translated by Adili. Tehran: Hamam Publications. (In Persian)
  39. Roostaei, Bahman. (2017). History of Economic Developments in Kabul and its Impact on Urban Planning. Urban Development Magazine, New Era (34,35), 5-13. (In Persian)
  40. Salehi Babamiri, Chia., Molaei Hashjin, Nasrallah., Motamedi Mehr, Akbar. & Amar, Teymour. (2016). Trend Analysis of Evolution in the Socio-Cultural Structures of the Peri-Urban Villages, Case Study: Saqqez City -Kurdistan Province. Journal of Research and Rural Planning, 5(16), 61-76. (In Persian)
  41. SASAKI. (2017). Urban Design Framework Kabul City (Baseline Conditions Report). Kabul.
  42. Steiger, James H (2017). Exploratory Factor Analysis with R, Accessible from: http://www.statpower.net/Content/312/Handout/Exploratory%20Factor%20Analysis%20with%20R.pdf.
  43. UN-Habitat. (2015). Knowing Kabul, A Potential Powerhouse of Social and Economic Development. Kabul.
  44. Varesi, Hamid Reza., Mohammadi, Jamal. & Jafari Nodoushan, Mohammad Reza. (2018). Factors of Formation of Native Housing in the Neighborhoods of Meybod City. Journal of Geographical Urban Planning Research, 6(1), 197-213. (In Persian)
  45. Yazdani, Mohamad Hasan., Hassanpour, Sahar. & Hashemi Masoomabad, Reza. (2019). Spatial Analysis of Social and Physical Dimensions of Housing in Ahwaz City. Journal of Physical Social Planning, 6(2), 51-66. (In Persian)
  46. Zarkash, Afsaneh. (2009). The Role and Influence of State Factors on Private Buildings Architecture in the First Pahlavi Era. Book of the Month of Art (136), 14-24. (In Persian)
  47. Zebardast, Esfandiar. (2017). Exploratory Factor Analysis in Urban and Regional Planning, Case Study: Assessing Social Sustainability in Tehran Metropolis. Journal of Fine Arts - Architecture and Urban Planning, 22(2), 5-18. (In Persian)
Volume 15, Issue 1 - Serial Number 27
September 2024
Pages 23-41

  • Receive Date 09 December 2022
  • Revise Date 01 March 2023
  • Accept Date 05 June 2023