Assessment of peripheral development of selected bus stations based on transit-oriented development (TOD) criteria; Case study: Shiraz city

Document Type : Original Research Paper

Authors

1 Associate Professor, Department of Urban Planning & Design, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran.

2 M.A. in Urban Planning, Department of Urban Planning & Design, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran.

Abstract
Extended Abstract
Background and Objectives: Along with the emergence of the industrial revolution in the 18th century and the rapid growth of urbanization, many challenges for policymakers and planners in formulating urban management strategies arose. Among these challenges is the integrated and coordinated planning of urban development along with the development of public transportation in cities. To solve this problem, transit oriented development (TOD) is emphasized. This model, by preventing urban sprawl, aims to achieve sustainable development, which ultimately brings many positive economic, physical, and environmental effects to cities. The experiences of other countries in this regard also indicate a reduction in urban residents’ dependency on private cars. This study, by providing a brief review of the theoretical foundations of the subject and examining similar research, seeks to implement TOD principles in the surrounding areas of selected bus stations in the city of Shiraz. The bus fleet, as the most important public transportation mode in Iran, which is not dependent on specific routes and has lower establishment costs compared to other modes of public transportation, has been neglected. While,  most of domestic studies in the field of TOD focus on metro stations (mass transit). Furthermore, the bus network in Shiraz has evolved over time based on temporary needs and demand-driven approaches, aiming to provide services in line with the city’s physical and population growth. However, for various reasons, it currently accounts for a small share of urban transportation. Therefore, to increase the role of bus services in intra-city transportation, and in parallel with strengthening Transit-Oriented Development (TOD), the bus stations of Shiraz have been selected for study. So,This research aims to investigate the degree of adaptation of peripheral developments of selected bus stations in Shiraz with TOD principles by using SAW and TOPSIS methods, and provide effective solutions to upgrade and improve the condition of the surrounding areas of selected bus stations in Shiraz city.
Methods: The present study is considered an applied research, as it seeks to improve an urban infrastructure. Both library and field methods were used to collect information and data for this research. The research process begins with identifying the dimensions and indicators of Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) by considering the frequency of indicators used in similar studies and preparing a questionnaire to determine the weight of the indicators. The sampling method used in this research is the snowball method. This method is used to identify experts in the field of TOD (Transit-Oriented Development). The weight of the indicators are also calculated using the Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP Fuzzy) method. Next, the value of each indicator in each area is measured using GIS software, and finally, the area with the highest alignment with TOD principles is identified using the SAW method. In the end, the most optimal area in each dimension is determined using the TOPSIS method. The significance of this work lies in identifying the strengths and weaknesses of each area based on the TOD dimensions and providing suitable solutions for each area.
Findings: The findings of this research lead to the identification and prioritization of the most important indicators used in studies related to Transit-Oriented Development (TOD). Additionally, the level of alignment between the development surrounding selected bus stations in Shiraz and TOD principles, as well as their strengths and weaknesses in each dimension, are identified. Ultimately, this research revealed that, despite appropriate policymaking, the areas surrounding bus stations in the city of Shiraz have not experienced desirable development.
Conclusion: Overall, the results of this study show that the areas surrounding the Shahid Dastgheyb, Valiasr, and Namazi bus stations have the highest level of alignment with TOD principles, respectively. The indicators of Entropy, density of existing metro stations and bus stops in the area and Average cost of land and buildings are identified as the most important factors influencing the implementation of TOD. Among the various dimensions of TOD, the dimensions of diversity and design are the most significant. The study also highlights that most TOD research has focused on metro stations, neglecting bus stations despite their importance in the urban transportation system. As a result, many weaknesses were found in this area, indicating the need for further attention and research.

Graphical Abstract

Assessment of peripheral development of selected bus stations based on transit-oriented development (TOD) criteria; Case study: Shiraz city

Highlights

- Application of SAW and TOPSIS methods to assess the conformity of peripheral developments of selected bus stations in Shiraz with TOD principles.
- The importance of three indicators: entropy, the density of public transportation stations, and the average cost of land and buildings among the factors influencing the implementation of the TOD approach.

Keywords

Subjects


  1. Abdi, M. (2015). Evaluating Experiences of Transit-Oriented Development toward Planning in Iran Conditions, Traffic Management Studies, 9(34), 119- 146. [In Persian]
  2. Akharinkhabar. (2022, July 7). Shiraz has the highest per capita bus fleet in the country. [News]. Retrieved 2023, Apr. 12, from https://akharinkhabar.ir. [In Persian]
  3. Austin, M., Belzer, D., Benedict, A., Esling, P., Haas, P., Miknaitis, G., Wampler, E., Wood, J., Young, L., & Zimbabwe, S. (2010). Performance-Based Transit-Oriented Development Typology Guidebook, Center for Transit-Oriented Development
  4. Babbie, E. (2010). The Basics of Social Research (5nd ed.). Wadsworth.
  5. Esfandiari Dorabad, F., Pirouzi, E., & Amini, Z. (2016). Locating Optimal Direction for Physical Extension of Shiraz City by Using VIKOR Method. Geographical Planning of Space, 6(20), 99-116. [In Persian]
  6. Higgins, C. D., & Kanaroglou, P. S. (2016). A latent class method for classifying and evaluating the performance of station area transit-oriented development in the Toronto region. Journal of transport geography, 52, 61-72.
  7. Hossini, S. J., Rajabi, A., Safahan, A., & Rezvani, A. (2022). Analysis of the Situation and Effects of Transit Oriented Development (TOD) in Districts 11 and 12 of Tehran City. Journal of the Studies of Human Settlements Planning (Journal of Geographical Landscape), 17(2 (59)), 547-562. [In Persian]
  8. Huang, R., Grigolon, A., Madureira, M., & Brussel, M. (2018). Measuring transit-oriented development (TOD) network complementarity based on TOD node typology, The Journal of Transport and Land Use, 11(1). https://doi.org/10.5198/jtlu.2018.1110
  9. Ibraeva, A., de Almeida Correia, G. H., Silva, C., & Antunes, A. P. (2020). Transit-oriented development: A review of research achievements and challenges. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 132, 110-130. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tra.2019.10.018
  10. Ibrahim, S. M., Ayad, H. M., & Saadallah, D. M. (2022). Planning transit-oriented development (TOD): a systematic literature review of measuring the transit-oriented development levels. International Journal of Transport Development and Integration, 6(4), 378- 398. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aej.2022.12.053
  11. Iranian Statistical Centre. (2016) Iranian Population and Housing Census 2016. [Report]. Retrieved 2023, May 8, from https://amar.org.ir/population-and-housing-census [In Persian]
  12. ISNA. (2024, May 26). 60% of Shiraz people use private cars. [News]. Retrieved 2024, June 8, from https://www.isna.ir. [In Persian]
  13. Izady, H., & Abbaspoor, Z. (2020). Identification of Effective Criteria for Implementing Transit-Oriented Development Projects (TOD) in Iran: A Meta-Synthesis Approach. Traffic Management Studies, (56), 115-144. [In Persian]
  14. Jafarpour, A., Mohammadi, E., & Salehi, P. (2017). Feasibility study of implementation of transit-oriented development model (TOD) in Tehran metro station areas. The 5th recent international conference on engineering. Iran University of Science and Technology, Tehran, Iran. [In Persian]
  15. Javadi, Gh., Taleai, M., & Karimi, M. (2013). Evaluating Various Criteria for Determining Diversity of Urban Mixed Land Use Via GIS (Case Study: Neighborhoods and Districts of Tehran Municipality No.7). Urban-Regional Studies and Research (University of Isfahan), 4(16), 23-46. [In Persian]
  16. Joshi, R., Joseph, Y., Patel, K., & Darji, V. (2017). Transit-oriented development: Lessons from international experiences. Working Paper 38. Centre for Urban Equity (CUE), CEPT University. Ahmedabad.
  17. Kazazi Darani, S., Akbari Eslami, A., Jabbari, M., & Asefi, H. (2018). Parking Lot Site Selection Using a Fuzzy AHP-TOPSIS Framework in Tuyserkan, Iran. Journal of Urban Planning and Development, 144(3). 04018022-1-10. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)UP.1943-5444.0000456
  18. Kermanshahi, S., Ramandi, A., Bashiri nia, M., Mirmoghradaee, M., & Shokrgozar, M. (2023). Developing a TOD-based Evaluation Method for Urban Development Plans: A Case Study of Neyshabour's Master Plan. Quarterly Journals of Urban and Regional Development Planning, 8(25), 1-41. https://doi.org/10.22054/urdp.2023.67998.1453. [In Persian]
  19. Kermanshahi, Sh., Sadeghi, M., Ramandi, A.R., Bashirinia, M., Shokrghozar, M., Shamkhani Esfahani, H., Ghasemi, M., Harirchian, M., Momeni, M., & Mirmoghtadaei, M. (2022). Guidelines for the evaluation of the Urban Development and construction plan in accordance with the principles of transit-oriented development (TOD) (first ed). Road, housing and Urban Development Research Center. [In Persian]
  20. Kumar, P. P., Sekhar, C. R., & Parida, M. (2020). Identification of neighborhood typology for potential transit-oriented development. Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 78, 102186. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trd.2019.11.015
  21. Larimian, T., Sadeghi, A., & Abdollah, B. (2012). Prioritization of effective indicators in implementing the Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) approach using fuzzy hierarchical analysis technique. 11th Transportation and Traffic Engineering Conference of Iran. Tehran. [In Persian]
  22. Li, Z., Han, Z., Xin, J., Luo, X., Su, S., & Weng, M. (2019). Transit oriented development among metro station areas in Shanghai, China: Variations, typology, optimization and implications for land use planning. Land use policy, 82, 269-282. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2018.12.003
  23. Lyu, G., Bertolini, L., & Pfeffer, K. (2016). Developing a TOD typology for Beijing metro station areas. Journal of Transport Geography, 55, 40-50. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2016.07.002
  24. Mahpour, A., Amiri, P., & Farzin, I. (2021). Prioritizing TOD Indices Using analytic hierarchy process for the case of Tehran Metropolis. Journal of Transportation Research, 18(2), 81-90. https://doi.org/10.22034/tri.2021.117577. [In Persian]
  25. Moayeri, M., Haghshenas, h., & Tahmasebi, B. (2018). Prioritization of Suitable Areas for Implementing Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) Policy Using GIS Software: A Case Study of Isfahan City. The 17th International Conference on Traffic and Transportation Engineering. [In Persian]
  26. Mohammadi Zanjirani, D., Salimifard, Kh., & Yousefi Dehbidi, Sh. (2014). Review the performance of the most common Multi-Indicator decision techniques with an optimization approach. Journal of Operational Research and Its Applications (Applied Mathematics), 11(1), 65-84. [In Persian]
  27. Momeni, M. (2014). New research topics in operations (Sixth ed.). Moalef publisher. Tehran, Iran. [In Persian]
  28. Persian Khodro. (2017, May 25). 400 vehicles are registered daily in Shiraz. [News]. Retrieved 2023, Apr. 12, from https://www.persiankhodro.com. [In Persian]
  29. Pour Mohammadi, M. R., Sadr Mousavi, M. S., & Hossein Abadi, S. (2016). Evaluation of land use mixture in neighborhoods of Sabzevar city. Journal of Arid Regions Geographic Studies, 6(22), 34-53. [In Persian]
  30. Raisi, H., & Paknahad, M.R. (2015). Examination of the challenges of transit-oriented development (Tod) case study: districts 1,5 and 7 of Shiraz. First National Conference on Urban Planning, Urban Management and Sustainable Development. Tehran. [In Persian]
  31. Ranjbar, H., Akbar Haghdoost, A., Salsali, M., Khoshdel, A., Soleimani, M., & Bahrami, N. (2012). Sampling in qualitative research: a Guide for beginning. Annals of Military and Health Sciences Research, 10(3), 238-250. [In Persian]
  32. Rasoolzade Sheikh, Sh., Haghighi, F., & Azmoode, M. (2018). Evaluation of Pedestrian Access in Land use with Transit-Oriented Development Approach (Case study: Zone 6 of Tehran). Urban Management, 17(52), 159-170. [In Persian]
  33. Russo, R.D., & Camanho, R. (2015). Criteria in AHP: A Systematic Review of Literature. Procedia Computer Science. Volume 55, 1123-1132. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procs.2015.07.081.
  34. Shahabian, P., & Asadi, R. (2017). Assessing the Implementation the Functional Principles of Transit-Oriented Development in the Shahrak-e Ekbatan Complex Station. Environmental Based Territorial Planning (Amayesh), 10(36), 133-156. [In Persian]
  35. Shoa Haghighi, A. (2015). Feasibility study of the implementation of transit-oriented development TOD in the city of Shiraz. 1st National Conference on Civil Engineering & Architecture & Sustainable Development. Yazd. Iran. [In Persian]
  36. Soltani, A. (2015). Comparative Evaluation of Exclusive Busway Performance from the Passengers Viewpoint, the Case Study of Namazi to Zand Busway, Shiraz. Geography and Environmental Planning, 26(1), 35-52. [In Persian]
  37. Su, Sh., Zhang, H., Wang, M., Weng, M., & Kang, M. (2021). Transit-oriented development (TOD) typologies around metro station areas in urban China: A comparative analysis of five typical megacities for planning implications. Journal of transport geography, 90, 102939. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2020.102939
  38. Taherdoost, H. (2017). Decision Making Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP); A Step by Step Approach. International Journal of Economics and Management Systems. Volume 2, 244-246.
  39. Tamakloe, R., & Hong, J. (2020). Assessing the efficiency of integrated public transit stations based on the concept of transit-oriented development. Transportmetrica A Transport Science, 16(3), 1459-1489.  https://doi.org/10.1080/23249935.2020.1753849
  40. Zabihi, H., Abdolah, B., & Abdolah, B. (2016). Evaluating and Determining the Role of Darvazeh-Dolat Station Complex with Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) Approach. Urban Management Studies, 8(26), 19-30. [In Persian]
  41. Zhang, Y., Song, R., van Nes, R., He, S., & Yin, W. (2019). Identifying Urban structure based on transit-oriented development. Sustainability, 11(24), 7241. http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/su11247241
Volume 15, Issue 1 - Serial Number 27
September 2024
Pages 175-190

  • Receive Date 05 July 2023
  • Revise Date 05 September 2023
  • Accept Date 11 November 2023