Keywords = Postmodern Architecture
Number of Articles: 2
History in Deconstructive Architecture: An Analysis of the Discourse of History in Jacques Derrida’s Thought and Deconstructive Architecture

History in Deconstructive Architecture: An Analysis of the Discourse of History in Jacques Derrida’s Thought and Deconstructive Architecture

Volume 16, Issue 1, July 2025, Pages 257-272

https://doi.org/10.30475/isau.2025.396238.2113

Seyed Soroush Sadri, Manouchehr Foroutan, Seyed Mahmood Moeini, Hossein Ardalani

Abstract Extended Abstract
Background and Objectives: Architectural history in recent centuries has been predominantly explained through grand narratives, stylistic classifications, and the linear continuity of architectural developments. Within this approach, architectural works are regarded as manifestations of the “spirit of the age,” and their value and meaning are interpreted within a continuous historical system based on architectural styles. In contrast, post-structuralist thought, particularly the ideas of Jacques Derrida and Bernard Tschumi, has challenged grand narratives and opened up the possibility of rereading history in terms of discontinuity, multiplicity of meaning, and the absence of a central signifier. Drawing on the concepts of deconstruction, discourse, signifier, signified, difference, trace, absence, and critical history, the present study examines the formation of the discourse of deconstructive architectural history and seeks to demonstrate how architectural history can be understood not as a fixed and closed narrative, but as a dynamic network of meanings, readings, and continuous reinterpretations. The main research problem concerns how deconstructive architectural history rereads the architectural past and how this approach differs from conventional narratives of architectural history. Accordingly, the study aims to explain the theoretical foundations of the discourse of deconstructive architectural history, identify its fundamental components, and compare this approach with classical architectural historiography. The study also seeks to demonstrate that deconstruction is not merely a formal or aesthetic approach, but rather a theoretical framework for rethinking the concepts of history, meaning, and the identity of architectural works.
Methods: The research adopts a qualitative, descriptive-analytical methodology based on discourse analysis. Data were collected through documentary research, including books, scholarly articles, and theoretical writings on deconstruction, architectural history, and contemporary architectural theory. The analytical framework is primarily derived from Jacques Derrida’s philosophy of deconstruction, while also incorporating discussions of discourse and architectural criticism found in contemporary architectural literature. The study systematically analyzes concepts such as discourse, différance, trace, absence, presence, floating signifiers, binary oppositions, and the critique of metaphysics. These concepts are then examined within the context of architectural historiography to identify their influence on historical interpretation. Moreover, selected architectural works, particularly those designed by Peter Eisenman, are examined as practical manifestations of deconstructive thought in architectural design and historical representation.
Findings: The findings demonstrate that deconstructive architectural history fundamentally differs from conventional architectural historiography. Instead of presenting history as a chronological sequence of styles and movements, it interprets history as a plurality of competing discourses whose meanings remain unstable and continuously open to reinterpretation. Architectural history, therefore, becomes a textual field in which no single narrative can claim absolute authority. The study reveals that Derrida’s critique of metaphysical presence undermines the assumption of fixed and permanent historical meanings. Architectural works are consequently understood as systems of signs whose meanings emerge through relationships of difference rather than through essential or original identities. Accordingly, historical interpretation shifts from the discovery of an objective past toward the production of multiple critical readings of architectural texts. The research further indicates that deconstruction emphasizes marginalized narratives, neglected architectural traditions, and overlooked historical voices. Rather than reinforcing dominant historical accounts, deconstructive historiography seeks to expose hidden assumptions and reveal the ideological structures underlying established historical narratives. As a result, architectural history evolves from a closed and hierarchical discipline into an open interpretive process.
Conclusion: The study concludes that deconstructive architectural history provides an alternative theoretical framework for understanding the relationship between architecture and history. By rejecting fixed historical narratives and embracing multiplicity, ambiguity, and critical interpretation, deconstruction reconceptualizes architectural history as an open discourse rather than a definitive historical record. This approach expands the scope of architectural historiography by incorporating forgotten narratives, questioning dominant historical assumptions, and emphasizing the interpretive nature of historical knowledge. It also demonstrates that architectural meaning is never fixed but is continuously reconstructed through cultural, social, and intellectual contexts. Ultimately, the discourse of deconstructive architectural history offers significant theoretical potential for contemporary architectural research, criticism, and historiography. It encourages scholars to reconsider the foundations of historical interpretation and provides new methodological possibilities for investigating architectural texts beyond conventional stylistic and chronological frameworks.

An analysis of the expression of meaning in postmodern architecture from a linguistic perspective (Comparison of the application of rhetorical devices in postmodern language and architecture)

An analysis of the expression of meaning in postmodern architecture from a linguistic perspective (Comparison of the application of rhetorical devices in postmodern language and architecture)

Volume 13, Issue 1, May 2022, Pages 165-180

https://doi.org/10.30475/isau.2020.216256.1345

Zahra Ahmadi, Hassan Zolfagharzadeh

Abstract Extended Abstract
Background and Objectives: Language or linguistic system is one of the most fundamental principles in twentieth-century philosophical studies and postmodern philosophy. The twentieth-century scholars considered “language” as the basis of thought - not its tool. According to them, truth, i.e., objective reality and whatever it is, is formed in language. Thus, the revival of thought in the form of language has changed the issues of cultural criticism of postmodernism. The linguistic theory has simultaneously paid attention to meaning and symbolism in architecture. The way of conveying meaning in language and applying linguistic knowledge through linguistic similarities with architecture was studied through paradigms such as semiotics. The founders of semiotics, Ferdinand de Saussure (1857-1913) and Charles Sanders Peirce (1839-1914), considered language as a system of signs with structural (syntactic) and semantic aspects. Rhetorical devices are one of the tools used to form and recognize meaning. Most contemporary semiologists consider studying these techniques, or at least some of their features, in the realm of semiotics. The verbal language of postmodernism uses rhetorical devices to form meaning. Previous studies have not addressed the role of metonymy and its interaction with metaphor in the formation and expression of meaning in the language of postmodern architecture. Therefore, the research question is: “How do rhetorical devices influence the expression of meaning in language and architecture?” So, the present study aims “to study how rhetorical devices are formed and how they operate in forming and transferring meaning, as well as decoding and reproducing it in postmodern architecture.” This study is significant because in societies such as Iran, which are influenced by Western thoughts, knowing the opportunities and threats of applying these thoughts enhances architects’ and designers’ creativity and minimizes cultural damages caused by accepting such thought currents.
Methods: To answer the research question and reach the research goal, the semiotics of Saussure and Peirce, as well as Barthes’s mythology, were studied in linguistics, and the data obtained from them were compared with architecture. Then, the rhetorical devices of metonymy, metaphor, amphibology, and irony were defined in verbal language and semiotics. Their formation and functions were compared with postmodern architecture in two paradigmatic and syntagmatic axes. The analyses were performed using Charles Jencks’ (1939-2019) definition of postmodern architecture as well as his interpretation of the New State Gallery (Neue Staatsgalerie (1977-1983) in German) in Stuttgart, Germany. Then, the results were examined in several other buildings. So, the present study was qualitative-applied research. Data were collected by library study. Then, they were analyzed descriptively and comparatively using a semiotic approach and case studies.
Findings: According to Saussure’s linguistics, architecture is a language without the intrinsic and natural relationship between its signifier (body) and signified (meaning). What is perceived as the architectural meaning is the outcome of conventions between the architect and audiences. While, according to Pierce’s semiotics and the referral system of its signs, architecture is a language in which rhetorical devices, especially metaphor and its interaction with metonymy, play a crucial role in its “genesis” and “function.” Metaphor is formed on the paradigmatic axis and metonymy on the syntagmatic axis. The interaction of metaphor and metonymy also forms other rhetorical devices in architecture, such as irony and amphibology. The body of architecture changes and transforms with the formation of metaphor and its meaning with the metonymy formation. From this point of view, for some reasons, the architecture language, especially postmodern architecture, can be considered to have a metaphorical and rhetorical pattern. These reasons are:
a) The referential system of this language,
b) The proliferation, multiplicity, difference, and suspense of meaning follow this system in this language, and
c) Changes in the architecture’s body and the meaning follow metaphor and metonymy and the interaction of the two.
On the other hand, the combination of the Saussurean and Peircean models indicates that postmodern architecture has a movement toward a single meaning. However, the totality of this meaning is suspended in its language’s metaphorical and rhetorical system. Postmodern architecture reproduces and develops concepts such as pluralism, contradiction, pleasure, and complexity through its postmodern signs and rhetorical devices. In contrast, comparing its features with the concept of “myth” defined by Barthes showed that postmodern architecture uses the architectural elements of the prior contexts and impoverishes their meanings without suppressing them by making fundamental changes in their layers and codes. Then, using rhetorical devices, combining the explicit and implicit meanings of the elements and “making them its own,” it imposes itself on the cultures as the ideology while shaping the facts.
Conclusion: Just as architecture can develop, multiply and enrich linguistic symbols, meanings and concepts, language also has the power to encode or “give meaning” to architectural signs. Thus, understanding the function of rhetorical devices, especially the metonymy and metaphor interaction, makes it possible to decode and reproduce the meaning of any complex rhetorical architecture through semiotic analysis. In addition, using these devices to express thought in the architectural design makes the semantic richness of the resulting architecture possible.