Exploring the key drivers of community-led regeneration for enhancing urban livability in distressed areas; Case study: Anjirab neighborhood in Gorgan

Document Type : Excerpted from a doctoral thesis

Authors

1 Ph.D. Candidate in Urban Planning. Department of Architecture and Urban Planning, Faculty of Engineering, North Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Urban Planning, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract
Extended Abstract
Background and Objectives: Urban spaces have experienced significant transformations over time, resulting in both physical and functional deterioration. In recent years, governmental and municipal entities have implemented various strategies to revitalize and reconstruct these deteriorated urban areas. However, the substantial volume of deteriorated structures, coupled with the partial and prolonged execution of projects, underscores the inadequacy of these approaches. According to available statistics, approximately 1,350,000 hectares of deteriorated and informal settlements exist within the country’s urban areas, accommodating around 20 million individuals. This situation presents a critical challenge due to two primary concerns: firstly, residents are susceptible to damages from natural hazards such as earthquakes and floods because of substandard construction quality; secondly, these residents are more vulnerable in terms of income, employment, and access to services compared to other urban dwellers. The lack of sufficient funding, inadequate collaboration among various institutions, structural and infrastructural instability, use of non-standard materials, absence of desirable construction qualities, and environmental degradation highlight the urgent need for policies focused on regeneration and resilience enhancement of these settlements. Anjirab, a neighborhood in the city of Gorgan, serves as an example of an informal settlement. Like similar neighborhoods, it is characterized by a heterogeneous population, unauthorized and non-standard constructions, employment in informal sectors, poverty, low income, high immigration rates, and a diverse demographic structure. As generations and the socio-cultural composition of this community evolve, so do the expectations and demands of these low-income groups. Since this neighborhood was built by immigrants without adhering to architectural and urban planning principles, the current study aims to identify the factors influencing its livability.
Methods: This article aims to identify and categorize the drivers of community-led regeneration in Anjirab neighborhood to enhance its livability, utilizing a structured analytical approach. Theoretical data were obtained through bibliographic research, while empirical data were gathered via a Delphi technique survey. The statistical sample consists of 20 urban experts selected through purposive sampling. The development drivers encompass 44 driving forces across five dimensions: economic, social, physical, institutional-management, and environmental, analyzed through the Cross-impact analysis method in MICMAC.
Findings: The system environment analysis reveals that 218 factors exhibit tertiary relationships, indicating significant interaction and mutual influence among key drivers. Further research findings suggest that the driving forces are dispersed in a complex, intermediate state concerning their influence and effectiveness, with clustering patterns showing a concentration of drivers in the independent sector. Of the 44 driving forces, nine have a substantial impact on the future state of community-led regeneration in the Anjirab neighborhood: organized local organizations, attraction of regeneration funds, the attitudes and knowledge of city managers, inclusion of community-led regeneration in urban plans, establishment of specific regulations for regeneration, alignment of plans with residents’ needs and lifestyles, strengthening the role of neighborhood councilors, enhancement of the land’s economic value, and allocation of government funds. Systemically, these forces aim to improve urban environmental quality, positioning them as the most effective and critical drivers.
Conclusion: This research aims to identify the drivers influencing the future state of community-led regeneration in Anjirab neighborhood of Gorgan, with the goal of improving its livability. The findings indicate that the general pattern of dispersion of the studied drivers, based on mutual effects analysis, reveals an unstable environmental system. These drivers display a complex and intermediate state in terms of effectiveness. Clustering analysis shows that the drivers are primarily concentrated in the independent forces sector. Among the 44 driving forces, nine have a key impact on the future of community-led regeneration in Anjirab, with a focus on enhancing livability. The results suggest that the growth and development of community-led regeneration in Anjirab require well-organized local organizations. These organizations can strengthen communication between residents and improve coordination of regeneration activities. Furthermore, attracting financial resources from both domestic and international sources is essential. These funds would facilitate the implementation and improvement of neighborhood regeneration plans and the creation of necessary infrastructure. The attitude and knowledge of city managers are crucial to the success of community-led regeneration. City managers must possess a deep understanding of community-led regeneration concepts and the skills necessary to implement related plans. Additionally, integrating community-led regeneration into urban planning is vital. Urban plans should not only address the needs and challenges of residents but also promote local community strength and solidarity. The establishment of specific laws to support community-led regeneration is also essential. These laws should provide the necessary motivation and support for regeneration activities while addressing local needs and challenges. Plans should be tailored to the needs and lifestyles of the residents, ensuring that design and implementation processes are aligned with their desires and requirements. Strengthening the role of neighborhood councilors can also significantly support community-led regeneration and improve livability. Councilors, who are local residents, can leverage their social credibility to effectively mobilize opinions, communicate with residents, and act as a liaison among all stakeholders.

Graphical Abstract

Exploring the key drivers of community-led regeneration for enhancing urban livability in distressed areas; Case study: Anjirab neighborhood in Gorgan

Highlights

- Identifying the key drivers affecting the state of community-led regeneration.
- Classification of development driving forces in 5 dimensions including economic, social, physical and institutional-managerial and environmental and processing them with structural interaction analysis method in MICMAC.
- Presenting suggestions for the realization of community-led regeneration in order to improve the livability of Anjirab neighborhood in city of Gorgan through the identified key drivers.

Keywords

Subjects


این مقاله برگرفته از رساله دکتری نویسنده نخست با عنوان «تبیین الگوی بازآفرینی اجتماع‌محور در جهت ارتقاء زیست‌پذیری بافت‌های ناکارامد شهری؛ نمونه موردی: کوی انجیراب گرگان» می‌باشد که به راهنمایی نویسنده دوم و مشاوره آقای دکتر مصطفی بهزادفر در دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی واحد تهران شمال انجام گرفته است.

This article is derived from the first author`s doctoral thesis entitled “A community-led approach toward livable urban regeneration in urban distressed area; Case study: Anjirab Neighborhood, Gorgan”, supervised by the second and advised by Dr. Mostafa Behzadfar, at Islamic Azad University, North Tehran Branch.

 

  1. Adams, D.; Hastings, E.M. (2001). Urban regeneration in Hong Kong: Transition from development corporation to renewal authority. Land Use Policy, 18, 245–258.
  2. Ahadnejad Rushti, M., Meshkini, A., Heidari, M.T., Rasuli, M. (2022). Regeneration Analysis of Urban Decay Textures with Emphasis on the Role and Function of Local Stakeholders with a Foresight Approach (Case Study: Zanjan City): Journal of Research and Urban Planning. 13 (48): 51-68. [in Persian]
  3. Akbari, M., Tahirpour, F., Bostan Ahmadi, V., & Fuladi, A. (2019). Structural-interpretive modeling of factors affecting the development of religious tourism in Iran with a future research approach. Tourism and Development, 9(4), 285-296. [in Persian]
  4. Anjirab neighborhood assessment report. (2019). A research plan to evaluate and monitor the implementation of the national program for prevention, control and reduction of social harms in the less privileged (marginalized) neighborhoods, Golestan Governorate. [in Persian]
  5. Ariana, A., Kazemian, G., & Mohammadi, M. (2020). Conflict management model of urban regeneration stakeholders in Iran (Case study: Hemmat-abad neighborhood of Isfahan. Motaleate Shahri, 9(35), 117-132. [in Persian]
  6. Askarian, R., Khorrambakht, A., Ebrahim Afifi, M. (2022). Preparing a Model for Integrated Planning and Management of Historical Textures in Order to Regeneration (Case study: Tabriz Metropolis).; 12 (47): 219-236. [in Persian]
  7. Barani, M., Abdollahzade T., Akbar, Faramarzi Asli, M. (2022). Measuring the factors affecting sustainable urban regeneration in the worn-out fabric of Urmia city (case study of the central fabric of the city). Sustainability, Development and Environment, 3(2), 25-46. (in Persian)
  8. Bruce, A., Clarson, D., (2017). Assessing the potential and limits of community-based initiatives in urban regeneration: three decades of experience on Sheffield’s Manor estate, Regional Studies, Regional Science,4:1,80-93.
  9. Chahardowli. M. Sajadzadeh. H. Aram. F. Mosavi. A. (2020). Survey of Sustainable Regeneration of Historic and Cultural Cores of Cities. Energies. 13. Publisher: MDPI.11.50-72.
  10. Chatterton, P., & Bradley, D. (2000). Bringing Britain Together: The limitations of area-based regeneration policies in addressing deprivation. Local Economy, 15(2), 98-111
  11. Daroudi, M.h, Khoshab, A. (2014), Evaluation and analysis of indicators for determining the scope of worn-out urban structures in Iran, the 6th National Conference on Urban Planning and Management with an emphasis on the components of the Islamic city, 21st and 22nd of November 2014, Mashhad. [in Persian]
  12. Deakin, M. (2009). A community-based approach to sustainable urban regeneration. Journal of Urban Technology, 16, 91–112.
  13. Esmailpoor, N., Piroozmehr, D., Akbari, R., & Esmailpoor, F. (2022). Explaining the social factors affecting residents' participation in community-based regeneration in dysfunctional urban contexts (Study case: ghalah Vakil Abad neighborhood, Mashhad). Spatial Planning, 12 (3), 1-4. [in Persian]
  14. Ghannad, F., Sarrafi, M. (2019). The Strategic Planning of Akhund Neighborhood in Qazvin City with Community-led Urban Regeneration Approach. Journal of Geographical Urban Planning Research (GUPR, 7(2), 211-238. [in Persian]
  15. Ghorbani, R., Asghari Zamani, A., Tahooni, M. (2023). An analysis of the factors affecting the instability of urban neighborhoods for sustainable regeneration (Case study: Northern neighborhoods of the historical-cultural context of Tabriz). Journal of Research and Urban Planning, Vol 14, No 54, PP:15- 36. [in Persian]
  16. Habibi, M & Khabeiri, S. (2018). Urban regeneration policy: views and necessities. Haft Shahr, 4(62), 22-27. [in Persian]
  17. Hajipour, Kh. (2007). An introduction to the evolution and development of urban restoration approaches during the period after World War I to the beginning of the third millennium,Andisheh Iranshahr Magazine, (4), 43-46. [in Persian]
  18. Hanachi, P & Fadaei Nezhad, S. (2011). A Conceptual Framework for Integrated Conservation and Regeneration in Historic Urban Areas: Journal of Fine Arts: Architecture & Urban Planning, 3(46),15-26. [in Persian]
  19. Hodosney, H. (2015), Urban regeneration management with an emphasis on local governance patterns, research sample: Tehran city, urban planning doctoral thesis, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran. [in Persian]
  20. Hui, E.C.; Liang, C.; Yip, T.L. (2018). Impact of semi-obnoxious facilities and urban renewal strategy on subdivided units. Appl. Geogr., 91, 144–155
  21. Izadi, M.s. (2018). Special editor's speech; Urban regeneration approach: towards a new urban agenda. Haft Shahr, 4(62), 8-15. [in Persian]
  22. Jin, E., Lee, W., and Kim, D., 2018, Does Resident Participation in An Urban Regeneration Project Improve Neighborhood Satisfaction: A Case Study of "Amichojang" in Busan, South Korea, Sustainability, Vol.  10, PP.1-13
  23. Kalantari, Kh. H, & Poorahmad, A. (2005). Techniques and Experiences of Planning the Restoration of the Historical Context of Cities. Tehran: University Jihad Publishing Organization, 3(7), 105-116. [in Persian]
  24. Keshavarzi, P., Beyk Babaei, B., Hosseinzadeh Delir, K. (2022). Analysis of the Relationship between Cultural and Social Regeneration and Neighborhood Development (Case study: Southern Dizaj Neighborhood of Bonab City): Journal of Research and Urban Planning. 13 (48): 153-168. [in Persian]
  25. Korkmaz. C. and Balaban. O. (2020). Sustainability of urban regeneration in Turkey: Assessing the performance of the North Ankara Urban Regeneration Project. Habitat International.95. 63- 87.
  26. Liu, Y., shen, L., Ren., Y., & Zhou, T (2023). Regeneration towards suitability: A decision-making framework for determining urban regeneration mode and strategies, Habitat International., Vol., 102870.
  27. Lotfi, S. (2011). Culture-led Regeneration: A Reflection upon Cultural Fundaments and the Act of Regeneration, Journal of Fine Arts: Architecture & Urban Planning.3(45),49-62. [in Persian]
  28. Miśkowiec, M. and Masierek, E. (2022). Factors and levels of community participation using the example of small-scale regeneration interventions in selected neighbourhood spaces in Polish cities. Urban Research & Practice, 1-25
  29. Momeni, M., Beik Mohammadi, H., Mehdizadeh, Z. (2010). An analysis of plans for revitalization and renovation of worn-out tissues, a case study of Joibare neighborhood of Isfahan. Journal of Urban and Regional Studies and Research (Discontinued), 2(7), 31-52. [in Persian]
  30. Nejad Ebrahini, A & najdaghi, N. (2018). Defining the Conceptual Framework of Community-Led Urban Regeneration Based on Training in the Historic Zones. Urban Planning Knowledge, 2 (3),21-34. [in Persian]
  31. Noring, L. (2019), Public Asset Corporation: A new vehicle for urban regeneration and infrastructure finance. Cities, 88:125–135
  32. Nourian, F & Ariana, A. (2012). Analyzing Judicial Support for Public Participation in Urban Regeneration, Case Study of Imam Ali Square (Ateegh) in Isfahan, Journal of Fine Arts: Architecture & Urban Planning,17(2),15-28. [in Persian]
  33. pakro N, Sattarzadeh D. (2022). Investigating the Effective Components of Institutional Challenges of Citizen Participation in Sustainable Urban Regeneration Case Study: Tabriz City. jgs; 22 (65) :79-101. [in Persian]
  34. Pazzini, M., Corticelli, R., Lantieri, C., Mazzoli, C. (2023). Multi-Criteria Analysis and Decision-Making Approach for the Urban Regeneration: The Application to the Rimini Canal Port (Italy). Sustainability, 15, 772.
  35. Pourahmad, A., Habibi, Ki Keshavarz, Mahnaz. (2010). The evolution of the concept of urban regeneration as a new approach in worn-out urban contexts. Iranian Islamic City Studies, 1(1), 73-92. [in Persian]
  36. Pourahmad, A., Keshavarz, M., Ali Akbari, E., & Hadavi, F. (2017). Sustainable regeneration of urban inefficiency tissues under study (Zone 10 of Tehran). Environmental Research, 10(37), 194-167. [in Persian]
  37. Roberts, P. & Sykes, H. (2000). Urban Regeneration: a Handbook. London: SAGE Publications.
  38. Roberts, P. (2000). “The evolution, definition and purpose of urban regeneration”. In P. Roberts and H. Sykes (eds.), Urban Regeneration A Handbook, London: Sage Publications, pp. 9-36.
  39. Smith, I. Urban Regeneration in Europe; Couch, C., Fraser, C., Percy, S., Eds.; Blackwell Publishing: Oxford, UK, 2004; Volume 21, pp. 270–271.
  40. Williams, G. D.  (2023). Enabling the practices in an urban regeneration system of provision, Regional Studies, Regional Science, 10(2), 167-183.
  41. Wolfram, M. 2016. Conceptualizing urban transformative capacity: A framework for research and policy. Cities 51: 121–130.
  42. Zare, A, Shams al-Dini, A, & Meshaksar, P. (2023). Investigating the performance of integrated urban management in the regeneration of worn-out urban tissues (case study: Fakhrabad neighborhood - Shiraz metropolis). Urban future research quarterly. 3(1), 40-70. [in Persian]
  43. Zhong X, & Leung HH. (2019). Exploring Participatory Microregeneration as Sustainable Renewal of Built Heritage Community: Two Case Studies in Shanghai. Sustainability. 2019; 11(6):1617.
  44. Zhou, Yulin, Lulu Wei, Feng Lan, Xiang Li, and Jing Bian. 2022. "Evaluation and Optimization on Urban Regeneration Sustainability from the Perspective of Multidimensional Welfare of Resettled Resident—Evidence from Resettlement Communities in Xi’an, China" Land 11, no. 8: 1258. https://doi.org/10.3390/land11081258
Volume 15, Issue 2 - Serial Number 28
December 2024
Pages 141-157

  • Receive Date 16 January 2024
  • Revise Date 30 March 2024
  • Accept Date 25 April 2024