بررسی تأثیرساختار کالبدی حیاط مرکزی در تهویه طبیعی خانه‌های سنتی یزد؛ نمونه موردی: خانه‌های لاری‌ها و گلشن

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 استادیار، گروه معماری، دانشکده مهندسی معماری و شهرسازی، دانشگاه تربیت دبیر شهید رجایی، تهران، ایران.

2 دانشجوی دکتری معماری، گروه معماری، دانشکده معماری و شهرسازی، دانشگاه تربیت دبیر شهید رجایی، تهران

3 دانشجوی کارشناسی‌ارشد، گروه معماری، دانشکده معماری و شهرسازی، دانشگاه شهید بهشتی، تهران، ایران.

چکیده
حیاط مرکزی به عنوان عنصری بنیادین در خانه‌های سنتی اقلیم گرم و خشک ایران شناخته می‌شود که نقش موثری در تهویه مطلوب فضاهای مجاور خود دارد. مقاله حاضر در پی آن است که به بررسی ابعاد کالبدی حیاط مرکزی بپردازد و نسبت مناسبی برای آن بیاید. لذا این پژوهش که از نوع ترکیبی کمی و کیفی می‌باشد با استفاده از روش تجربی-آزمایشی، خانه های لاری ها و گلشن یزد در محیط نرم افزار دیزاین بیلدر شبیه سازی و مدلسازی شده است و بدین صورت سطح اثرگذاری عمق و ارتفاع در میزان تهویه طبیعی از طریق محاسبه الگوی گردش و سرعت باد در حیاط مرکزی این خانه ها مورد ارزیابی قرار گرفته است. نتایج تحقیق نشان داده است که‌ تغییرات در عمق و ارتفاع حیاط، با فرض ثابت بودن طول و عرض آن، در الگوی گردش هوای حیاط مرکزی و متعاقباً تهویه طبیعی به شدت موثر است. در حیاط‌های نمونه پس از افزایش ۲ متری ارتفاع، رابطه‌ای مستقیم بین میزان ارتفاع حیاط با میزان سرعت باد وجود دارد اما بعد از اعمال تغییر ارتفاع به میزان ۴متر و ۶ متر، رفتار باد تغییر پیدا می‌کند و با افزایش ارتفاع، سرعت باد در حیاط کاهش می‌یابد. در مجموع پس از تحلیل جریان هوا، ارتفاع مناسب حیاط مرکزی جهت عملکرد مطلوب تهویه طبیعی در خانه گلشن 9 متر و در خانه لاری‌ها 11متر می‌باشد.

تازه های تحقیق

- روش تحقیق از نوع ترکیبی کمی و کیفی (راهبردهای تجربی، شبیه‌سازی و پژوهش موردی) و مدل‌سازی در نرم‌افزار Design Builder.
- بررسی تغییرات ارتفاع حیاط مرکزی در الگوی گردش هوا و تهویه طبیعی.

کلیدواژه‌ها

موضوعات

عنوان مقاله English

Examining Investigating the Effect of the Central Courtyard Structure on the Natural Ventilation of Traditional Houses in Yazd; Case Study: Lariha and Golshan Houses

نویسندگان English

Omid Rahaei 1
Milad Omidi 2
Amir Hossein Shirdel 3
1 Assistant Professor, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Engineering, Shahid Rajaee Teacher Training University, Tehran, Iran.
2 Ph.D. Candidate in Architectur, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Engineering, Shahid Rajaee Teacher Training University, Tehran, Iran.
3 M.A. Student in Architectur, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Architecture .and Urban Planning, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran
چکیده English

Extended Abstract
Background and Objectives: The central courtyard is one of the important architectural elements of traditional houses in hot and dry regions of Iran, which plays a major role in organizing space, improving climatic conditions, and providing comfort to residents. The physical dimensions of this courtyard, especially its depth and height, are effective in temperature balance and natural ventilation, and have a great impact on the surrounding air flow, especially in hot summers. Traditional Iranian architecture has provided suitable solutions to deal with heat by using this element appropriately. However, scientific investigation of the appropriate dimensional ratios of the central courtyard is still one of the research needs of Iranian architecture, especially in the contemporary period when attention to indigenous patterns and new technologies has increased. The aim of this research is to analyze the effect of the dimensions of the central courtyard, especially its depth and height, on natural ventilation in traditional houses in hot and dry regions of Iran, and by simulating the houses of Lariha and Golshan in Yazd, it seeks to determine the optimal dimensions to improve the quality of ventilation and thermal comfort, and to apply these findings in modern architecture.

Methods: This research is of a quantitative and qualitative type, and experimental, test, and case study strategies have been used to conduct it. The data collection method includes library studies, observations, field observations, measurements, and simulations. Since the aim of the research is to investigate the improvement and performance of natural ventilation of the central courtyard in traditional Iranian houses, the dimensions of the central courtyard were considered as the independent variable and the air circulation pattern inside the courtyard as the dependent variable. The statistical population of this research includes houses with a central courtyard in Yazd and two houses in Lariha and Golshan, Yazd, as study samples, which were also selected in a non-randomly targeted manner. Initially, field measurements of the dependent variable (airflow speed and direction) were taken as primary data and simulation validation was carried out over a 30-day period, 3 times a day (9 am - 12 noon and 3 pm) in August, using a 200kimo/v device. Then, the measured data and the 3D model of the case samples were simulated using Design Builder software with the aim of analyzing the air circulation pattern in the central courtyard. Finally, the variable size of the height of the central courtyard was measured through intervention in the simulations.

Findings: The initial findings of this study indicate that the ventilation performance and air flow velocity in the central courtyard are very complex and are affected by many factors, but in order to simplify the study, only the effect of the courtyard height was investigated. In this regard, the air flow velocity at different heights of the central courtyard, including an increase and decrease in height by 2 meters, was simulated and compared. The results indicate that in both the Golshan and Lariha houses, increasing the height of the courtyard by 2 meters compared to the initial state causes a relative increase in the air flow velocity. For example, in the Golshan house, an increase in height of 2 meters increases the wind speed by about 9 to 20 percent, and in the Lariha house by about 11 percent. Similarly, a decrease in height by the same amount causes a significant decrease in the wind speed inside the courtyard. However, in the continuation of the study and with a further increase in height (up to 4 and 6 meters), the trend of changes was reversed; that is, an excessive increase in height caused a sharp decrease in the air flow velocity in the central courtyard, and in some cases, the speed reached close to zero. In contrast, a significant decrease in height (4 to 6 meters) also caused a significant increase in the average wind speed, approaching the speed of the outdoor air. Overall, these studies indicate a direct relationship between a moderate increase in courtyard height and air flow speed, but an excessive increase in height causes a significant decrease in ventilation and efficiency of the central courtyard. This finding indicates that the ratio of the height of the central courtyard should be selected carefully and based on ventilation optimization in order to maintain optimal conditions of thermal comfort and natural ventilation efficiency in traditional spaces.

Conclusion: In traditional houses in the desert regions of Iran, the central courtyard plays a key role in improving ventilation and air conditioning. This study, using computer simulation using Design Builder software, investigated the effect of changing the height of the central courtyard on the speed and pattern of airflow in Golshan and Lari houses. The results of the study show that increasing the height of the courtyard to 2 meters increases the speed of airflow in the courtyard space, and decreasing the height by the same amount reduces the wind speed. However, with a further increase in height, i.e. to 4 or 6 meters, the speed of airflow decreases and the previous relationship is reversed; in other words, too high a height causes a loss of ventilation. The results also indicate that an excessive decrease in the height of the courtyard also causes the height of the surrounding spaces to reach an impractical or unsuitable level for habitation, and side effects such as reduced shade and increased temperature in the courtyard are created. Based on these findings, the appropriate height for the central courtyard in order to achieve optimal ventilation in the Golshan house is 9 meters and in the Lari house is 11 meters.

کلیدواژه‌ها English

Natural Ventilation
Central Courtyard
Lariha House
Golshan House
Traditional House
Design Builder
  1. Aguilar, A.J., de la Hoz-Torres, M., Costa, N., Arezes, P., D. Martínez-Aires, M., Ruiz, D.P., (2022). Assessment of ventilation rates inside educational buildings in Southwestern Europe: Analysis of implemented strategic measures. Journal of Building Engineering. 51, 104204.
  2. Amidpour, Majid. (2009). Investigating the effects of using chimneyless heaters on indoor air quality, Research project, Khajeh Nasir al-Din Tusi University, Faculty of Mechanics, Client: Iran Fuel Consumption Optimization Company. ]In Persian[.
  3. Asadpour, F, Asadpour, A.(2014). Optimization of Energy Consumption Using Solar Bath in the Hot and Dry Climate of Iran, European Online Journal of Natural and Social Sciences: Proceedings,3(3),40-49.
  4. Asadpour, F., Khastoo, S., Rezaeian Fard, M.H., (2016). Using wind turbines in high-rise buildings in the development of sustainable architecture (case study: Kish Island). Journal of Fundamental and Applied Sciences, 8(3), 1069-1084.
  5. Asadpour, F., Shirdel, A. H., & Naghipour, P. (2024). Evaluation of perceptual indicators of physical environment affecting the inducement of citizen’s sense of place in urban neighborhoods. Energy and Buildings325, 114992.
  6. Asadpour. F., Habibi, A., (2015). Strategies for climatic design for sustainable urban housing development (case study of Nur City, mazandaran, Iran). Cumhuriyet Science Journal (Fen Bilimleri Dergisi), 36(6), 653-664.
  7. Azarbayjani, M., (2013). Comparative Perfor mance Evaluation of a Multistory Double Skin Façade Building in Humid Continental Climate. The Visibility of Research, UNCC.
  8. Bahar, Ali. (2016). Natural ventilation and cooling using the values of traditional Iranian architecture, Third International Conference on Research in Science and Technology, Berlin-Germany.]In Persian[.
  9. Banhidi, L.J., (1991). Radiant Heating Systems-Design and Applications, Pergamon Press.
  10. Burgess, W.A., (1995). Recognition of HealthHazards in Industry. New York: Wiley Ltd.
  11. Chung, L.P., Ahmad ,M.H.,Ossen ,D.R., Hamid, M ., (2015). Effective solar chimney cross section ventilation performance in Malaysia terraced house. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, V.179, 276-289.
  12. De la Torre, S., Yousif, C., (2014). Evaluation of Chimney Stack Effect in a New Brewery Using DesignBuilder-energyPlus Software, Energy Procedia, V.62, 230-235.
  13. Energy Information Administration, (1996). State Energy Data Report
  14. Fath-Alian, Afshin; Kargar Sharifabad, Hadi (2019). Investigating the effect of different energy optimization strategies on building energy classification using DesignBuilder software (Case study: Office building), Environmental Science and Technology, Volume 22, Issue 7, Serial 98, 199-214. ]In Persian[.
  15. Ghale Noei, Afsaneh. (2012). The effect of using natural ventilation on optimizing energy consumption, Second National Conference on Wind and Solar Energy, Tehran. ]In Persian[.
  16. Ghanbaran, Abdolhamid; Hosseinpour, Amin. (2013). Investigating the thermal behavior of double-skin facades in the climate of Tehran, Journal of Architecture and Sustainable City, Volume 1, Issue 2, Autumn and Winter, 43-53. ]In Persian[.
  17. Ghobadian, Vahid. (2012). Climatic architecture and sustainable architecture in Iran. Tarar Journal, Issue 5. ]In Persian[.
  18. Haeri Mazandarani, Mohammad Reza (2009), House, Culture, Nature (A Study of the Architecture of Historical and Contemporary Houses in Order to Compile the Process and Criteria for House Design), Tehran, Publication of the Urban Planning and Architecture Study and Research Center. ]In Persian[.
  19. Han, J., Yang, W., Zhang, G., Zhang, Q., Moschandreas, D.J. (2009). A comparative analysis of urban and rural residential thermal comfort under natural ventilation environment. Energy Build. 41, 139-145.
  20. Hassana. M.A, et al., (2007). Investigation of effects of window combinations on ventilation characteristics for thermal comfort in buildings, Desalination, V.209, 251–260.
  21. Heidari, Shahin; Ghafari Jabbari; Shahla. (2010). Thermal Comfort Zone in the Cold and Dry Climate of Iran, Fine Arts Journal, Volume 2, Issue 44, 37-42. .]In Persian[.
  22. Hezbaei, Morteza, Adib, Zahra and Nasrollahi, Farshad. (2014). Natural Ventilation in the Shevadans of Dezful City Using CFD Modeling, Bagh Nazar Journal, Issue 30, Year 11, 37-48.
  23. Indraganti, M., Boussaa, D. (2017). Comfort temperature and occupant adaptive behavior in offices in Qatar during summer. Energy and building. 150, pp23-36.
  24. Indraganti, M., Ooka, R., Rijal, H.B., Brager, G.S., (2014). Adaptive model of thermal comfort for offices in hot and humid climates of India. Building and Environment Journal. 74, 39-53.
  25. Izadyar, N., Miller, W., Rismanchi, B., Garcia-Hansen, V. (2020). A numerical investigation of balcony geometry impact on single-sided natural ventilation and thermal comfort, Building and Environment Journal. V. 177, 106847.
  26. Jomehzadeh, F., Hussen, H.M., Calautit, J.K., Nejat, P., Ferwati, M.S. (2020). Natural ventilation by windcatcher (Badgir): a review on the impacts of geometry, microclimate and macroclimate. Energy and Buildings. 226, 110396.
  27. Jomehzadeh, F., Nejat, P., Calautit, J.K., Yusof, M.B.M., Zaki, S.A., Hughes, B.R., Yazid, M.N.A.W.M. (2017). A review on windcatcher for passive cooling and natural ventilation in buildings, Part 1: indoor air quality and thermal comfort assessment. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 70, 736–756.
  28. Kasmaei, Morteza. (2013). Climate and Architecture. Tehran, Khak Publishing. ]In Persian[.
  29. Kasmaei, Morteza. (2016). Climate and Architecture. Tehran: Khak Publishing. ]In Persian[.
  30. Koch-Nielsen, Halger. (2017). Natural Ventilation: A Guide to Climate Design for Hot Regions, Translated by Ahmadinejad, Mohammad, Khak Publishing. ]In Persian[.
  31. Mehdinejad, Jamal-edin and Shirdel, Amir Hossein. (2024). Analysis and ranking of factors affecting sustainable housing design in the cold and dry climate of Sabzevar based on energy consumption optimization, Sustainable Architecture and Environment Journal, Volume 2, Issue 6. ]In Persian[.
  32. Mehdinejad, Jamal-edin and Shirdel, Amir Hossein. (2024). The wisdom of Iranian housing architecture based on energy consumption optimization, First and Last Publications, Tehran. ]In Persian[.
  33. Mehdinejad, Jamal-edin and Shirdel, AmirHossein. (2024). Identity Elements of Iranian House Architecture, First and Last Publications, Tehran. ]In Persian[.
  34. Mirsajadi, Seyed Amir, Farkish, Hiro. (2016). Evaluation of patterns and recognition of effective physical factors in the architecture of historical houses of Neyshabur to achieve design solutions and house construction patterns in traditional residential context. Islamic Architecture Research. Volume 4, Issue 4, 72-92. ]In Persian[.
  35. Moradi, Sasan; Matinrad, Mehrdad; Fayyaz, Rima; Dehbashi Sharif, Mazin. (2018). Typology of Traditional Courtyard Houses in Tabriz Based on Physical Criteria Effective on the Climatic Performance of the Central Courtyard, Urban Management Journal, Volume 17, Issue 51, 87-105. ]In Persian[.
  36. Naghipour, Peyman, Naghipour, Afshin, Shirdel, Amir Hossein, Zanganeh Behzadi, Sara, Rahaei, Omid, Salamati, Samaneh.(2025). Sustainability in Historical Islamic Architecture: Lessons from Sheikh Lotfollah Mosque’s Construction Techniques, Journal of Islamic Architecture,8(3),585-603.
  37. Nomura, M., Hiyama, K. (2017). A review: natural ventilation performance of office buildings in Japan. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 74, 746–754.
  38. Omrani, S., Garcia-Hansen, V., Capra, B., Drogemuller, R. (2017). Natural ventilation in multi-storey buildings: design process and review of evaluation tools. Building and Environment. 116, 182–194.
  39. Pesaran, Arash, Kariminia, Shahab, Nazemi, Elham and Toghiani, Shirin. (2019). Recognizing the role of paimon in the design of traditional houses from the perspective of static cooling (Case study: Qajar houses in Shiraz) Bi-Quarterly Journal of Architectural Thought, Year 3, Issue 6, 160-174. .]In Persian[.
  40. Poirazis, H. (2004). Double Skin Facades for Office Buildings: Literature review, Report EBD-R-04/3, Department of Construction and Architecture, Lund University.
  41. Pourmand, Hassan Ali; Riteshgaran, Mohammad Reza. (2006). The Truth of Place and Space in Architecture, Islamic Art Studies, Spring and Summer, Issue 4, 43-60. .]In Persian[.
  42. Rahai, Omid, Salehi, Sedighe Sadat and Shirdel, Amir Hossein. (2024). Improving the natural ventilation in the classrooms of Masjed Soliman schools based on the condition of the openings and external shading blades using the CFD method. Sustainable Architecture and Urbanism Journal, Volume 12, Issue 1. .]In Persian[.
  43. Rahai, Omid. (2013). Cultural identity and its effects on indigenous methods of natural ventilation of the old market of Dezful, Rasteh Sanatgaran. Bagh Nazar, 10(24), 39-46. .]In Persian[.
  44. Rahai, Omid. (2014). Investigation of the process of indoor air flow and its analytical models in small industrial sheds using the CFD method, Sustainable Architecture and Urbanism Journal, Volume 2, Issue 2, Fall and Winter, 55-64. .]In Persian[.
  45. Rahai, Omid. (2021). Investigating the physical changes of central courtyards on their air flow patterns in Qajar-era houses in Isfahan using CFD method (case study: Labaf House), Journal of Architecture and Sustainable City, 9(2), 25-46.]In Persian[.
  46. Rahai, Omid; Azmati, Hamid Reza. (2019). Improving the quality of natural ventilation in school classrooms in Mazandaran province based on the condition of openings using CFD method, Journal of Architecture and Urban Planning of Iran (JIAU), 11(1), 57-71 .]In Persian[.
  47. Rahspar Monfared, Reza; Azmati, Saeed. (2021). Analysis of wind behavior in natural ventilation and reduction of energy consumption in a residential building based on vernacular architecture, case study: The effect of opening dimensions and placement on natural ventilation in the city of Amol, Arman Shahr Architecture and Urban Planning Journal, Volume 14, Issue 35, 103-114 .]In Persian[.
  48. Rouhi, S, Valibeig,V, Khodayari Mafi,M, Shirdel,A.(2024). Retrieve Khaju Bridge Architecture and Surrounding Landscape and Environment based on Visual and Descriptive Documents, Journal of Revitalization School,2(3),36-47.
  49. Saadati Nasab, Mehran; Zolfaghari, Seyed Alireza; Norouzi Jajarm, Elahe; Moslehi, Hamed. (2014). Analysis of the Effects of Using Double-Skin Facade as a Solution on Energy Conservation in Iranian Residential Buildings Using DesignBuilder Software, Third International Conference on New Approaches in Energy Conservation, Iran. ]In Persian[.
  50. Saebi Safa, Bahar; Heydari, Fatemeh; Soleymanpour, Negar. (2019). Auditing the amount of energy loss through the external walls of the building and the effect of thermal insulation with simulation in DesignBuilder software (Case study: Office building in Tehran), Journal of Science and Engineering Elites, Volume 5, Issue 3, 169-179. ]In Persian[.
  51. Saflaei, Farzaneh. (2005). The Environmental Impact of the Central Courtyard in Sustainable Residential Architecture in Hot and Dry Areas of Iran, PhD Thesis in Architecture, supervised by Dr. Seyed Majid Mofidi Shemirani, Islamic Azad University, Tehran Science and Research Branch. ]In Persian[.
  52. Schulze, T., Gürlich, D., Eicker, U. (2018). Performance assessment of controlled natural ventilation for air quality control and passive cooling in existing and new office type buildings. Energy and Buildings. 172, 265–278.
  53. Shirdel, Amir Hossein , Mehdinejad, Jamal al-Din. (2024). Explaining the principles of smart housing architecture with the aim of reducing the use of non-renewable energy in order to preserve the environment, Journal of New Research, Volume 4, Issue 4. ]In Persian[.
  54. Shirdel,A, Aasdpour, F, Rahaei, Omid.(2025). Manifestation of Islamic Teachings in the Design of Tranquil Homes (Case Study: Aldaghi and Jafarzadeh Houses in Sabzevar), Architectural Technologies Studies,16(2).
  55. Shiri, Tohid, Dideban, Mohammad and Taban, Mohsen. (2018). The effect of form on the amount of shading and heat absorption in the dome of Yazd water reservoirs, Quarterly Journal of Islamic Architecture Research, Volume 7, Issue 25, 75-92. ]In Persian[.
  56. Soflaei, F., Shokouhian, M., Zhu, W. (2017). Socio-environmental sustainability in traditional courtyard houses of Iran and China. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, V.69, 1147-1169.
  57. Soltanzadeh, Hossein. (2011). The role of geography in the formation of courtyard types in traditional Iranian houses, Journal of Human Geographical Research, Volume 43, Issue 1, Serial 75, 69-86. ]In Persian[.
  58. Soltanzadeh, Hossein. (2016). Tabriz: Solid Brick in Iranian Architecture, Tehran, Cultural Research Office Publication. ]In Persian[.
  59. Sources:
  60. Taban, Mohsen; Pourjafar, Mohammad Reza; Bemanian, Mohammad Reza; Heydari, Shahin (2013). Determining the optimal pattern of the central courtyard in traditional Dezful housing based on the analysis of the received shadow of different levels of the courtyard, Bagh-e-Nazar, Volume 10, Issue 27, 39-48. .]In Persian[.
  61. Tavakoli, Seyed Mostafa; Baghaei, Abdullah; Safari, Hossein. (2015). Simulation of building facade openings on energy consumption by DesignBuilder software (Case study: Anzali rural house), Second International Conference on Modern Research in Civil Engineering, Architecture and Urban Planning, Istanbul, Türkiye. .]In Persian[.
  62. Vakilinejad, Rosa. (2016). The combined effect of physical characteristics of the building envelope and natural ventilation patterns on energy consumption in residential buildings (a case study of one-way ventilation buildings in the hot and dry climate of Shiraz), PhD thesis, supervised by Dr. Majid Mofidi and Dr. Fatemeh Mehdizadeh Seraj, Iran University of Science and Technology. ]In Persian[.
  63. Vassella, C.C., Koch, J., Henzi, A., Jordan, A., Waeber, R., Iannaccone, R., Charri`ere, R. (2021). From spontaneous to strategic natural window ventilation: improving indoor air quality in Swiss schools. International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health, 234, 113746.
  64. Yazdi, Yasman; Mofidi Shemirani, Seyed Majid; Etesam, Iraj. (2019). Design criteria in the structure of the central courtyard and summer hall of Qajar houses in Yazd, Journal of Islamic Art Studies, Volume 15, No. 34, 93-111. ]In Persian[.
  65. Yin, H., Liu, C., Zhang, l., (2019). Measurement and evaluation of indoor air quality in naturally ventilated residential buildings, Indoor Built Environment journal. No13, p.1-17.
  66. Zainlian, Nafiseh and Okhuvat, Hanieh. (2017). The architecture of the courtyard in Qajar houses in hot and dry and hot and humid climates with a focus on the central courtyard type (case study: Yazd and Dezful houses, Iranian-Islamic City Studies, Volume 8, Issue 30, 15-29.]In Persian[.
  67. Zainlian, Nafiseh; Ahvoat, Hanieh. (2017). The Structure of the Courtyard in Qajar Houses in Hot and Dry and Hot and Humid Climates with a Focus on the Central Courtyard Type (Case Study: Yazd and Dezful Houses), Journal of Iranian Islamic City Studies, Volume 8, Issue 30, 15-29. ]In Persian[.
  68. Zarei, Mohammad Ebrahim and Mir Dehghan, Fadlallah. (2016). The role of the central courtyard pattern in moderating the harsh conditions of the hot and dry climate of the Yazd region, Iranian-Islamic City Studies, Volume 6, Issue 23, 5-18.]In Persian[.

مقالات آماده انتشار، اصلاح شده برای چاپ
انتشار آنلاین از 31 شهریور 1404

  • تاریخ دریافت 13 بهمن 1402
  • تاریخ بازنگری 19 خرداد 1403
  • تاریخ پذیرش 10 مرداد 1403